Amaze testdrive (from a dzire owner)
Externals,styling,build quality : Amaze's styling is neutral and it will not have polarised opinion as is with the quirky new Dzire. It looks like a proper three box car. Dzire in comparison has a more aggressive front end. It looks taller and wider. Somehow I felt the styling resembles previous generation (Dolphin) Honda city with the boot looking slightly overhanged compared to its compact nose when viewed from side. No doubt the boot is well integrated overall in the Amaze and it infact looks better than its hatchback version.
Overdose of chrome and too many slashes are meant to appeal general Indian public in particular. Doesnt look as global as say the Jazz. Build quality is light and not too different from what Dzire (slightly more solid) has to offer. Cars like Verito and Manza have much more heavy construction.
Interiors,comfort and space :
If you talk about interior quality,Honda has frankly provided decent quality for its segment and the quality is consistent throughout. The plastics and fabrics used have nothing to complain about Dzire has some better looking touches like fake wood finish,chrome dials,slightly better quality plastics to make it feel richer overall. But quality isnot uniformly good as some levers,power window switches etc feel cheap. While the quality is good, overall interior looks bit plane jane. Dashboard in particular is more function than form. Dzire's dashboard and interior ambience is clearly superior here. *Do check out the lower variants of Amaze where the dashboard looks even more basic. There is a big gap in the glovebox when closed, which isnot there in Brio ! *
Space management is excellent and Honda managed to generate volume as good as Sail from a 4 meter car. Front seats with those fixed headrests arent as bad as they sound. I felt it would provide decent support overall being wide enough. Outright driver comfort will still be there with Dzire's excellent front seats with good back support. Amaze isnot too far behind. Rearseat legroom in particular is almost as good as Honda City which was parked next to it. Headroom though is bit of a compromise for 6 feet guys like me (Not that Dzire is much better but still it offers slightly better head space). Width of the rear seat is best for two and I actually found the flat bench of Brio at rear to be more convenient for three people. You seat slightly higher in the Dzire at the back with more thigh support. Still Amaze will *have that legroom advantage and bigger windows to aid that sense of space.
400 litre boot space is sufficient for most families and there should be no complaints whatsoever. Somehow I felt Jazz's engineering brilliance and hatchback design can make it accomodate more luggage than Amaze. Anyway, hats off to Honda for such excellent space management compared to what you get in Dzire.
Engine,Gearbox and Performance : Honda's all new IDTEC engine is a cleverly engineered product. Crank the engine and the diesel clatter is evident. Its not grave silent at idle as is with Petrol Honda engines. NVH is not too bad either. Almost comparable to Dzire's DDiS unit. On the move though sound levels are on the higher side. Rev the engine, it can be annoyingly noisy even if you are sitting at the back. Dzire is definitely more silent than Amaze on the move. Shockingly the engine isnt as audiable outside ! I felt Amaze's noise level is comparable to what it is in Ford Figo's TDCi powerplant.
Interestingly the nature of the idtec is very similar to TDCI engine albeit with more punch. Turbolag is minimum and the car requires very less effort to pull from 1200-1400 rpm. Driveability is excellent and a boon if you spend most of your time in slow moving traffic. I tried to drive it in higher gears and the engine can definitely pull from 1400 rpm in topgear effortlessly. If you try something similar in a Dzire it will feel like it is about to die. For highway prospective you will require far lesser downshifts in case you deaccelarate for slow moving vehicles ahead. Turbo spools quite early to make things quite effortless. Power delivery is quite linear and there will be no sudden spikes as witnessed in Dzire. While the driveability is very good, the outright punch isnt as good as 100 PS sounds. The engine tuned for better fuel efficiency and it shows. The engine doesnt like being revved either. Its a low revving unit (even by diesel car standards) and feels better when worked around the torque available in lower and midrange. DDiS unit in Dzire (as per diesel engine standards) feels more free revving and you feel comfortable revving atleast 500 rpm higher in almost all gears. If you love pushing your car hard, DDiS feels bit more enthusiastic. IDTEC is responsive and driveable. There is a sense of urgency with Dzire's engine thanks to the turbo boost (turbokick as famously said !) at around 2000-2200 rpm which makes it feel faster than the 25 bhp gap between the two cars suggest.
Gearbox is typically Japanese and feels light and relatively short throw. Dzire is evenly matched with nothing to choose between the two. One special highlight of Amaze is its petrol like soft clutch. It will work like a blessing in crawling traffic. Just release the clutch in second gear and the car rolls. Dzire's clutch is heavier in comparison like a typical diesel. *
Dynamics,Suspension and Braking : Amaze's steering felt shockingly heavier than what I have ever witnessed in a Honda ! Maybe its because of more weight on the front tyres due to heavier engine. Its definitely not feather light as is in Brio or even City. Infact I felt Dzire's steering to slightly lighter. Back to back drive is required to have a definite conclusion. Dont get me wrong, the steering is still light compared to HPS units (ford,fiat) but a certain amount of extra effort is required compared to petrol Hondas. Heavier steering will be good thing to have on highways for better confidence at speed.
Ride quality is definite step up from Brio. Amaze doesnt crash like the Brio on potholed roads thanks to the longer wheelbase. It needs to be seen how the car behaves when fully loaded as the setup is on the softer side. Dzire's ride is bit more stable than Amaze's on uneven roads. Difference is minimal though Amaze transmits more road and suspension noise inside compared to Dzire.
Handling is predictable and adequate for the class of people it is targetted. For most of the driving cycle an average Amaze owner goes through,there will be nothing to complain about. Push the car and you will notice the body roll thanks to its soft suspension. Brio's go cart like feel is somewhat missing as sudden lane changes in Amaze isnt as quick. Dzire's body roll is definitely more controlled and I am sure it will corner better than the Honda. Straightline stability is almost evenly matched with Amaze feeling decently stable at 100-110 kmph (max I could push the car)
Amaze is effortless to drive in city thanks to its compact dimension and even better than Dzire for better visibility overall from pilot seats.
Braking as witnessed in Amaze is topclass. The feel of the pedals,body control and response time is very good. ABS as standard fitment on all models is like cherry on the top. Dzire's spongy brakes in VDi feels disappointing. *
Overall : Amaze is a very well engineered practical sedan which specifically designed keeping in mind the requirements of a prospective entry level sedan customer Space management is brilliant, the diesel powerplant is very practical for Indian driving conditions and the overall quality and value provided is very good. Presence of ABS as standard on all models is a welcome step by Honda. There are few shortcomings like cost cutting bits,noisy diesel engine and average dynamics but some of them can be tolerated keeping overall package in mind. Thumbs up Honda ! *
Dzire, I am sure has it own bits like better looking interiors,refinement and overall dynamics favouring. And the DDiS vs IDTEC comparo is more than what numbers suggest.
Amaze though is a more practical car with better space utilisation, more responsive and powerful engine and ofcourse better equipment distribution in lower and middle variants.
Last edited by Turbokick : 9th May 2013 at 02:26.
|