Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians

rtandon · 21st April 2011, 18:56

Can we make the "Previous" (<) & "Next" (>) links slightly bigger. I mostly read the posts on my phone and it is difficult to click the correct page link.
Cheers

laluks · 21st April 2011, 19:03

Is the thank you button only for members? Can any anonymous/non member reader thank for the info? This could be meaningful as the readership of the forum is so high that you get to know how much of the information that you posted really helped. As for the members I feel the emotional part of writing a thank you note will get converted to formal button click.

Anyways Thanks GTO for the feature. The button also clicked.

Thad E Ginathom · 21st April 2011, 19:11

Quote:

you will have an option to switch the PM-when-quoted function off.

The option seems to be there already

AltoHoncho · 21st April 2011, 19:25

GTO,
nice feature of 'thanks' although makes things a bit more mechanical but can be helpful in reducing the 'thanks' posts all across

Also, I have not seen an equally extensive coverage for bikes, like we have amazing TD and reviews for cars, ownership, forums like 'Indian Car scene', now that our bike (local as well as import) market is on a roll, we should start targeting that also. Something similar to the segment 'Indian Cars', there should be a section 'Indian Bikes / Bikes in India'.

There are quite a few experienced bikers and owners (across bike categories) who can definitely add value in a similar participative and expressive manner like we've for cars.

Also, the segment 'Indian Cars' should be retitled as 'Cars in India', there are imports being posted there and those are not Indian cars.

GTO · 21st April 2011, 19:33

Guys,

After extensive thought, we've proceeded with the "Thank You" feature. Please don't suggest removing it as we're beyond there.

Our main reservation against this hack was clutter (BHPians like it simple). We think we've taken care of that aspect very well by the + / - (expand / collapse) box. Thus, by default, if a post even has a 100 thanks, it doesn't clutter up the thread view at all.

There are a lot more tweaks pending to this hack, and which you'll see over the coming days.

Thanks

Recompose · 21st April 2011, 20:36

A nice feature to have. There are so many useful posts, and sometimes cant be thanked enough. Thanks! button is also a good way to reduce some 'Thanks' posts. But is there a way to undo these 'Thanks', as its quite possible to click on it whilst scrolling, thus evoking a

. ("Did I just thank him for congratulating XXX on his new car?").

If the "Like" button is not trademarked, we could consider using that. +1 too.

EDIT: Looks like its disappeared. Apologies if the post now sounds stupid.
EDIT 2: Looks like it hasnt. This does stupid now

roy_libran · 21st April 2011, 20:43

I for one, am already using this, and though I felt that LIKE was more generic and covered a wider variety of situations, THANKS is also fine.

Mr. Nobody · 21st April 2011, 20:49

very nice feature but yes do incorporate a way to unthank if accidently clicked like on pagalguy.com forums , also how about a no thanks button for the useless posts just below thanks buton ??

Warwithwheels · 21st April 2011, 20:52

Guys! don't you feel that we are being too finicky about this "Like/ thank" button. Please read thru' the quoted text.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GTO

Guys, After extensive thought, we've proceeded with the "Thank You" feature. Please don't suggest removing it as we're beyond there.
.............
.............
There are a lot more tweaks pending to this hack, and which you'll see over the coming days.
...........................

Looks like the support team have come up with this idea after much deliberation. Lets not be very finicky about this.

xingamazon · 21st April 2011, 20:57

Quote:

Originally Posted by GTO

Guys,

After extensive thought, we've proceeded with the "Thank You" feature. Please don't suggest removing it as we're beyond there.

Our main reservation against this hack was clutter (BHPians like it simple). We think we've taken care of that aspect very well by the + / - (expand / collapse) box. Thus, by default, if a post even has a 100 thanks, it doesn't clutter up the thread view at all.

There are a lot more tweaks pending to this hack, and which you'll see over the coming days.

Thanks

GTO, was interested to see if the number of Thanks has any relevance on the Grade of the member.

For e.g. are you planning to graduate a Sr. BHPian to a Distunguished BHPian based on the number of Thanks he receives. Or will it not have any impact on his grading.

Recompose · 21st April 2011, 20:58

Quote:

Originally Posted by Warwithwheels

Lets not be very finicky about this.

IMO, this doesn't really deserve a separate thread as this will turn out to be an unproductive endless discussion. Let's use this feature if we like it or ignore it if we don't. It is as simple as that.

I'm not against the 'Thanks' button at all! I appreciate it as a feature. All I'm saying is there should be as option to undo it, as sometimes, it can sound really irrelevant if you click it whilst scrolling down.

Example : "Did I just thank XXX for congratulating YYY on YYY's new car?".

vb-saan · 21st April 2011, 21:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by GTO

Guys,

After extensive thought, we've proceeded with the "Thank You" feature. Please don't suggest removing it as we're beyond there.

Thanks

Thanks GTO, happy to see new features around. And I personally liked the 'Thank you' feature, and also the PM when quoted option. By the way, what is the 3rd addition?

akp · 21st April 2011, 23:50

I fail to see how it would make one's forum experience more complex. On the contrary, this would eliminate posts that basically contain a "thank you" message, along with possibly some useless sentences to cross the minimum qualifying word limit. If someone has something good/interesting to post along with his "thank you" message, he is free to do that anyway, the button does not stop him.

Thanking someone for something useful is just good manners, that's all. Where do you see "insecurity" and "flattery" in it?

Thad E Ginathom · 22nd April 2011, 00:22

I wish that those that have things to say about THANKS would, please, rewind this thread, where they will find the matter extensively discussed. Probably most of the points, for and against, were made then.

To those who missed it at the time, well, I guess you missed it

Please, at least give the thing a few months before complaining. Anyway: it is easy enough to ignore.

I've noticed some people posting, "I thanked you." That is one of the things that was discussed: the THANKYOU as an alternative to those short posts.

suhaas307 · 22nd April 2011, 10:37

The 'Thanks' button seems to have been integrated pretty well. Better than when it was being 'tested' yesterday!

Good job Rush!

For some of us regular members, it's different and might take some getting used to. So what would be the other 2 new features?

21st April 2011, 18:56	#3601
rtandon BHPian Join Date: Nov 2009 Location: 1.37N 103.92E Posts: 71 Thanked: 41 Times	Re: Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians Can we make the "Previous" (<) & "Next" (>) links slightly bigger. I mostly read the posts on my phone and it is difficult to click the correct page link. Cheers
	() Thanks

21st April 2011, 19:03	#3602
laluks Senior - BHPian Join Date: Sep 2008 Location: Bangalore Posts: 6,552 Thanked: 16,397 Times	Re: Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians Is the thank you button only for members? Can any anonymous/non member reader thank for the info? This could be meaningful as the readership of the forum is so high that you get to know how much of the information that you posted really helped. As for the members I feel the emotional part of writing a thank you note will get converted to formal button click. Anyways Thanks GTO for the feature. The button also clicked. Last edited by laluks : 21st April 2011 at 19:06.
	() Thanks

21st April 2011, 19:25	#3604
AltoHoncho BHPian Join Date: Jul 2009 Location: Bangalore Posts: 581 Thanked: 14 Times View My Garage	Re: Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians GTO, nice feature of 'thanks' although makes things a bit more mechanical but can be helpful in reducing the 'thanks' posts all across Also, I have not seen an equally extensive coverage for bikes, like we have amazing TD and reviews for cars, ownership, forums like 'Indian Car scene', now that our bike (local as well as import) market is on a roll, we should start targeting that also. Something similar to the segment 'Indian Cars', there should be a section 'Indian Bikes / Bikes in India'. There are quite a few experienced bikers and owners (across bike categories) who can definitely add value in a similar participative and expressive manner like we've for cars. Also, the segment 'Indian Cars' should be retitled as 'Cars in India', there are imports being posted there and those are not Indian cars. Last edited by AltoHoncho : 21st April 2011 at 19:29. Reason: needed to add some more thought
	() Thanks

21st April 2011, 19:33	#3605
GTO Team-BHP Support Join Date: Feb 2004 Location: Bombay Posts: 70,534 Thanked: 300,734 Times View My Garage	Re: Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians Guys, After extensive thought, we've proceeded with the "Thank You" feature. Please don't suggest removing it as we're beyond there. Our main reservation against this hack was clutter (BHPians like it simple). We think we've taken care of that aspect very well by the + / - (expand / collapse) box. Thus, by default, if a post even has a 100 thanks, it doesn't clutter up the thread view at all. There are a lot more tweaks pending to this hack, and which you'll see over the coming days. Thanks Last edited by GTO : 21st April 2011 at 19:55.
	(13) Thanks

21st April 2011, 20:36	#3606
Recompose BHPian Join Date: Sep 2010 Location: Home Posts: 180 Thanked: 106 Times	Thank you - New feature on T-BHP! A nice feature to have. There are so many useful posts, and sometimes cant be thanked enough. Thanks! button is also a good way to reduce some 'Thanks' posts. But is there a way to undo these 'Thanks', as its quite possible to click on it whilst scrolling, thus evoking a . ("Did I just thank him for congratulating XXX on his new car?"). If the "Like" button is not trademarked, we could consider using that. +1 too. EDIT: Looks like its disappeared. Apologies if the post now sounds stupid. EDIT 2: Looks like it hasnt. This does stupid now Last edited by Recompose : 21st April 2011 at 20:46.
	(3) Thanks

21st April 2011, 20:43	#3607
roy_libran Senior - BHPian Join Date: Dec 2009 Location: DNCR Posts: 1,643 Thanked: 3,456 Times View My Garage	Re: Thank you - New feature on T-BHP! I for one, am already using this, and though I felt that LIKE was more generic and covered a wider variety of situations, THANKS is also fine.
	() Thanks

21st April 2011, 20:49	#3608
Mr. Nobody BHPian Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Gurgaon Posts: 517 Thanked: 614 Times	Re: Thank you - New feature on T-BHP! very nice feature but yes do incorporate a way to unthank if accidently clicked like on pagalguy.com forums , also how about a no thanks button for the useless posts just below thanks buton ??
	() Thanks

21st April 2011, 23:50	#3613
akp BHPian Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: New Delhi Posts: 320 Thanked: 177 Times	Re: Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians I fail to see how it would make one's forum experience more complex. On the contrary, this would eliminate posts that basically contain a "thank you" message, along with possibly some useless sentences to cross the minimum qualifying word limit. If someone has something good/interesting to post along with his "thank you" message, he is free to do that anyway, the button does not stop him. Thanking someone for something useful is just good manners, that's all. Where do you see "insecurity" and "flattery" in it? Last edited by GTO : 22nd April 2011 at 01:01. Reason: Removing quoted post which has been deleted
	() Thanks

22nd April 2011, 00:22	#3614
Thad E Ginathom Distinguished - BHPian Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Chennai Posts: 11,005 Thanked: 26,441 Times	Re: Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians I wish that those that have things to say about THANKS would, please, rewind this thread, where they will find the matter extensively discussed. Probably most of the points, for and against, were made then. To those who missed it at the time, well, I guess you missed it Please, at least give the thing a few months before complaining. Anyway: it is easy enough to ignore. I've noticed some people posting, "I thanked you." That is one of the things that was discussed: the THANKYOU as an alternative to those short posts.
	(1) Thanks

22nd April 2011, 10:37	#3615
suhaas307 Team-BHP Support Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: Bangalore Posts: 8,830 Thanked: 12,251 Times	Re: Suggestions for Team-BHP from Team-BHPians The 'Thanks' button seems to have been integrated pretty well. Better than when it was being 'tested' yesterday! Good job Rush! For some of us regular members, it's different and might take some getting used to. So what would be the other 2 new features?
	() Thanks