Quote:
Originally Posted by eltoro Hi Avi,
Just one question. I know you test rode both the bikes and the Bonnie won your heart over the Iron which made you go for it. But did you not consider the risk that your investment of 7 lakhs could potentially go bad if Triumph were to shut shop in India or offer poor service considering the way things have been shaping up after they launched in India till date?
Just to think about it no local mechanic would be able to even figure out how to open the engine leave alone fixing it. The peace of mind that Harley or even Honda/Kawasaki offer is way more than the comfort level with Triumph for me atleast.
Just wanted to know your thought process as I have been struggling with a similar dilemma but the only saving grace in my case is that Triumph has not even opened for business in the true sense in Bombay. |
I am sanguine that your apprehensions about Triumph 'shutting shop' and offering poor service in India(if it does not 'shut shop') has been adequately addressed by mobike008 and absynthguzzler.
I understand that you are quite erudite as far as bikes are concerned. Your culpable involvement for attaining peace of mind by acquiring a Harley/Honda/Kawasaki is astounding. But don't you feel that a bullock cart will help in achieving a higher state of nirvana as it has minimal chances of developing technical glitches?
Excuse my ignorance, but yet we don't end up investing in a bullock cart just because it has the least maintenance! There has to be some logic in the comparison, and ultimately choosing the Triumph over the Harley Davidson. If you accomplish the fact that Triumph is better than Harley Davidson, then you must buy the better ware! Why would you invest in something which is inferior just because your foreboding with a moniker which has entered our market recently. Holistically, both Triumph and Harley Davidson are new in this territory, ergo there are quite a few chances, if not equal, that HD 'shuts shop' here.
As far as opening the engine is concerned by a local mechanic, firstly, it is highly recommended that you belly up a non-local mechanic, duly taking advice of this forum and, secondly, why would you feel that one would requires to open up the engine in a hurry?! Pray relax. Triumph is a globally renowned marquee, which has been more appreciated than HD. It is not shutting shop anytime soon. And moreover, its endurance is phenomenal.
My take on the HD vis a vis Triumph goes back to 2006, when I got a chance to ride both the bikes neck to neck in Cape Town, South Africa. I must put on record that it has been 26 years that I've riding motorcycles, and that includes Bullets(with its associated glitches) also. After 1997, my garage always had a Bullet(till date). I had come across a few HDs in India, but never a Triumph(except in Auto Expos) till the time I reached Cape Town. My interest in motorcycles led me to read about both the brands earlier and I was armed with adequate theoretical facts. So, after reaching Cape Town I approached a vendor who used to rent out bikes. My hunger to ride a powerful machine led me to hire a Black 1600cc Harley Davidson. The power of the engine did put a smile on my face as I paid its rental for the fifteen day duration I intended to stay.
I submit my experiences very briefly with this motorcycle. The initial thrust of the bike was tremendous which I'm sure comes from the high torque figures. Straight line stability was immense and it was amazing to ride on an open road devoid of traffic. The sound was impressive(I'm not sure whether it had stock tail pipes or otherwise), which was obvious due to the size of the engine. Gradually, the bike started giving me a feel of a glorified Bullet. I felt similar kind of vibrations from the handle bars and my palms itched after longer rides. Riding it in the city and negotiating it around was a pain. To make a U-turn one had to plan in advance as its turning radius had figures on the higher side. Since, I was riding solo, it was at times quite arduous to pull it out in reverse from parkings, especially, when parked on the berm. It never delivered the sense of urgency to move. Although, the top speed figures were impressive, but reaching to such figures was not. In all, I used the steed for somewhere around 500 km when I started equating it into a cumbersome but an attractive piece of machinery.
With two thirds of my time of stay was still left in that place, I requested the vendor to change the bike to a very beautiful cherry red Triumph Bonneville 790cc. The vendor honored my request and I rode out on the Bonny feeling very much at home with the same stance of seating as the Bullet. I felt that it was equally attractive as the previous steed as this machine was producing a distinctive sound of a typical twin motor and as whole it looked very clean and uncomplicated compared to what I was riding the previous day. It handled like breeze in the traffic of city confines and was equally steadfast on the highway. To my astonishment it picked up speed faster that the bigger machine which I rode. The feel of torque from the bike was less but was up to snuff. The weight was very manageable and so was the size(It was not small to any standards). I could clock around a thousand km on this bike till it was the time for me to leave that country. The vibration levels were far lesser on this bike and hence it did not give a feel on itchiness on the palms and also since the fatigue to handle it was less it left me fresher and less tired.
By no means, Triumph is offering me any brownies for giving such a feedback, however, eltoro, it is recommended that you try out both the bikes before jumping to any conclusion and end up investing into something with false apprehensions.