Re: Less is More - VW Jetta Highline MT Early April, I took the plunge and decided on a Jetta. Even I am very surprised!
My earlier comments posted around were "looked like a Vento", "does not look that much of an upgrade from the Skoda".
My policy of changing cars every 50000km was long overdue. I decided I needed to look into this and started the hunt in December. I was looking for
1: Good handling
2: Punchy performance
3: Good quality
New or secondhand were not the criteria. What were considered?
1: Skoda Yeti
This was on top of my list - handling, rough roads capability, good build quality, decent stowage room. It ticked all the boxes. Went to the showroom and although I liked the car, something was bugging me.
Went to Vinayak twice. First test drive went ok, performance was good but dull after the vRS (unrealistic expectation). It handled well but high centre of gravity dulled things. Driving position and comfort was not totally right. Okay, it is an SUV and you need to expect compromises.
What did it in was the quality of the interior. I felt the Octavia had a more solid if spartan dashboard. The beige hard plastic door pads killed it for me.
To double check if I was not being picky, I took fellow mod Viddy with me for a another test drive. I managed to get comfortable and more at ease but the interior still did not gel. Bumped into Androdev who mirrored my viewpoint during a test drive
2: Skoda Superb Manual
Was loitering at TAFE Hosur Road and looked at the Superb. It had loads of kit and with the attractive discounts, made a compelling proposition. Frumpy looks and its sheer length put me off as also potential resale
3: Skoda Laura TSI/ vRS - new/used
Viddy and I tested a used TSI Ambient. It had strong performance but this was a poverty spec model without fog lights, etc. I felt it was no upgrade. Again the interior quality is down a notch on the Octavia and it was too beige for me!.
The performance was strong but not eventful unlike my vRS where you feel the turbo kicking in. so 1.8 TSi was eliminated. Add to that the Laura is in the last year or so of production. I must also add that the build quality is not as good as the Octavia
What was the final straw was my experience with Vinayak which I will discuss when the time is right. So Skoda got a lower priority Renault Fluence
An excellent car but no performance/ power. The interiors of this car sealed the fate of the Yeti since we literally jumped from the Fluence into the Yeti BMW 320d
I could have stretched added with tempting financial packages but lack of space and spare wheel were deal breakers. We had difficulties putting 5 people in a 5 series so imagine what the 3 could accomodate. Add to that, the 3 is not too exclusive nowadays so prices will suffer sooner or later Used 530d/ 525d E60
My ideal choice but none realistically priced Used Audi A6 3.0T
This was in Delhi but local lifetime tax plus difficulty when selling it on took this out Audi A4
CVT box whined me away New VW Passat
I could have tried to stretch to a Comfortline but the beige interior is overdone The Highline black interior is the one to have. Also it is not involving and size is too big for me
Old Passat 1.8 TSi used
I enquired about one but it went for Rs 17 Lakhs. I might have been tempted even though it was big. Old BMW 325 E46
This was a wild card for sale in Hyderabad, later hear that it had gearbox issues also old man and family have discouraged me from mature germans Chevrolet Cruze
Lots of kit, performance but driving dynamics and finish let it done Used Honda Accord
Many tempting propositions but beyond straight line performance, I was underwhelmed. Also there is a huge oversupply in the used car market
Hyundai Sonata
I wanted a car, not a sofa, also it is the automotive equivalent of having silver teeth
Not much else then?
Last edited by ajmat : 9th January 2019 at 18:07.
|