Re: 1st Gen Honda City Owners - Problems Areas, Fuel Efficiency and more Hi All,
I recently bought an OHC Vtech 2003 make, from a dealer in Mumbai and now have ran into a problem of broken crank pulley. Being new to this forum I was searching if anyone else had the same issue, and fortunately landed on this thread.
I saw a similar issue posted by AnkitAhuja a few pages back and now I am posting mine. Many thanks to Ankit who was really helping to talk to me at 11pm in the night and explaining me his problem and how he fixed it back. I am a total novice with cars and its internals. This being my first car, I was little worried until I talked to Ankit who adviced me to post this here for more valuable suggestions. The problem:
I last drove the car to Powai from my home in Goregaon(E) on saturday night(last weekend)when it was all fine. While returning at 3am I hit a speed breaker (which I saw very late due to bad lighting on the road) bit hardly. I was driving with my windows down an AC off. I paused for a minute after the bad bump to see if all is ok. Again started the car and headed back home. Drove back another 5kms to home and parked it. I dont recall getting any sounds after that bump and could get to home without any hassle. Only thing I worried at the time was my braking sytem which I thought needed a look.
So that day went by. The next day I started the car with AC on and it started making some noise. I was in a hurry, so I left the car and went by an Auto for the work thinking to get it checked later. Monday I did not use the car completely. Tuesday I decided to take off from office and get the car checked at Solitaire Honda(Borivali). I tried starting the car and it started making louder noise than before. I opened the bonnet to see if I caould see any issue. To my surprise I saw there are 3 belts to the right hand side of the engine very loose, almost geting out of thier pulleys. I also saw down below a broken rim from the pulley which was just hanging loose and was causing the rattling noise when I started the engine.
I called a local mechanic to have a look if he could fix the car so that I could take it to the service station. He told me that the main engine crank pulley which holds the 3 belts is broken and needs a replacement. He called up some shop in opera house and told me that it would cost about 3300 rupees to replace with new one. Then I called up Solitaire Honda to get some advice. The SA told me that its a costlier affair to replace crank pulley about 10-15K plus towing charges. After talking to him for a few minutes, he gave me frank opinion to get it replaced locally if possible as it would be cheaper. So I persisted with this local mechanic who confidently said to replace it in a day. I gave him 3500 to get the new pulley, he promptly called and ordered one.
Now the real problem starts, he started opening the bolt to which this crank pulley is attached to the engine. He tried very hard with his spanner and all to open it but failed after a number of attempts. He told me that this is the main bolt and is usually very tight and also it would not have been opened anytime before, so would take little more effort to get it loose. He went for lunch and came back after a couple of hours and continued trying to open it. Now we took the car to a nearby service area where he put it on a ramp and again tried to open. This time he got help from 2 more mechanics there but still no luck.
Now we took the car to his garage close by where he put some break oil and left to loose a bit. He tired all sorts of different tools, even beating with hammer and using a fire torch to heat it up. Nothing worked at all, and it could not be opened. Finally he told me that we'll put some oil and keep it overnight to try tomorrow. So I came back home feeling tired and a bit worried.
Next day(i.e today) I went to the office and in the afternoon called him up to get the status of the car. He said that he tried again in the morning but couldn't open it. So he ordered for a supposedly bigger and different spanner tool from Kurla from his friends garage there. He said that he'll again try with this is the evening and told me to relax and not worry at all. Now when I called him up late evening, he was still waiting for the new spanner and told me to wait for one more day. He again assured me that it will be done by tomorrow afternoon, an so here I am just waiting and hoping that it will be fixed.
In the night, I talked to Ankit who shared with me his experience with the same problem. I too fear that if the bolt gets broken in the process of opening, it would be more trouble to get the engine opened and then fix it correctly. Needless to say more money involved. Ankit already told me that the crank pulley should not cost more that 2000 bucks, for which I have already given3500Rs.
I am somehow getting a feeling that the mechanic is stalling me and will again quote me hefty sum. I wil see if he can open it in the morning without causing any damage, otherwise will get the car back and try someone else.
What should I do now? Need some advice/suggestions here. If anyone know any reliable and competent mechanic for Vtechs in Mumbai nearby Goregaon(E), I would highly appreciate that. Please let me know asap
Thanks in advance,
Vinay |