FG can be made stronger by adding more layers. But, for accoustic quality am not sure it is the perfect. In car audio, a sub always faces variarion in sound as per the cabin gain, different car and boot size offer different cabin gain, which could even make the sub sound boomy or tight. One particular sub in same enclosure could sound different in sedan to hatchback to SUV. Main Sound quality of the sub that its designed for always remains but the cabin gain makes the difference. To find a noticeable difference between the FG and MDF in a given vehicle is always tough for a human ear. And with the amount of equipement available one can always tune the sub, cutting or putting gain on particular frequency to make it sound as per required.
Since it's not much audible difference between the two that can be noticed, FG is preferred where sealed enclosure is concerned due to the flexibility. But, i guess there could be some reason where basic HT sub to high end to pro subs use MDF/HDF to even more expensive Rose wood.
Adding damping could lead to adding bit of reflection. I don't see a reason to apply damping when one is using 8 layers or more. The enclosure is strong enough for need of any damping. What I suggest is accoustical foams or open cell foam instead for better absorbtion of the freq. or may be some amount of polyfill just for the sake of cutting any standing waves.
In the end what matters is how much space is one willing to give up. FG or MDF is a personal choice although with the help of FG one can save more space by fitting the sub in a tight corner. JBL gti 12" has a displacement of .15 cu.ft and it requires anywhere between 1.25 to 1.50cu.ft. Frank try to figure out as per the boot what suits the best.
Last edited by Invinsible : 23rd August 2009 at 03:07.
|