Re: Renault Duster : Official Review Well I was gunning for the 85 Duster and also waiting for the Ecosport to arrive and arrive it did with a lot of hoopla. I went and test drove it. While I had instantly fallen in love with its looks (tail-gate mounted spare wheel, futuristic interiors) and the price, test driving the two back-to-back made me go for the Duster. These are the things that made me decide in favor of the Duster:
Ride and handling better than the Ecosport. My personal feeling.
Suspension is decidedly better than the Ecosport. Whereas in the Ecosport I could feel the judder of high-speed-crossing-of-a-hump right on to the steering, the Duster sailed over a similar one without any fuss.
Driving an Ecosport after having driven a Bolero made me feel like am in a really small car. The lack of visibility due to the A-pillar can't be ignored. It isn't confidence-inspiring at all. But driving a Duster after a Bolero made me grin from ear to ear. It is not much smaller and there's excellent visibility. Turning radius is SO much better than that of a Bolero.
The rear seat of an Ecosport was thumbed down by three of my generously endowed co-test-drivers (including my wife). They could easily fit into a Duster rear seat without much ado.
Yes, the Ecosport is offering a bang for your buck. The loaded Titanium diesel is available for 10. 5 lakhs on road, which is the same price as the Duster 85 RXE, which has almost nothing to offer. It is hugely overpriced and expect Renault to offer huge discounts by the end of this year because they are already pretty shaken by the launch of the Ecosport. The behavior at the Renault Whitefield (Bangalore) dealership has changed almost overnight. They are ready to allow insurance from outside even.
Overall, for the kind of driving I will do (mostly city) and occasional highway, and being basically a Bolero driver who isn't used to ANY frills at all, this Duster 85 RXE is a huge improvement. Am sure I will never learn to use any of Ford's Microsoft features and voice controls.
ABS should have been good, but I am a confident driver and there are two schools of thought about ABS. (Okay, can't afford, so grapes are sour, one can say.)
Why the RXE instead of the 85 RXL (O)? Well, again, economics. It is a whopping 3 lakhs more for ALMOST EVERYTHING that I wouldn't need. I will get alloys, ICE, and seat covers done from outside and also change to Yokohama Geolander A/T tyres if I can afford to.
So there you go. Booked a Woodland Brown 85 RXE at Renault Whitefield today. Mods that am fantasizing about (but will not go for for practical reasons):
Roof lights
Spare wheel on the rear door
Upsize Maxxis M/T tyres
Am I missing not having bought the Ecosport? Not really. Am smiling, kind of. 10.5 lakhs for a bare-bones sturdy car that's frugal on the highway and easy to drive in the city with my choice of ICE and seat covers. Reasonable buy. Now to look for a buyer for the Alto K10!!!
(Forgot to mention that GTO's review of the 85 really helped me decide. Thanks, GTO, that was a brilliant review.)
Last edited by Oreen : 2nd July 2013 at 20:20.
Reason: Forgot to thank GTO
|