In the last few das, more than before, these events have been in the news. I have glanced through the posts on this thread and have a few thoughts to share.
Firstly, it is clear that Indians & co, i.e. Bangladeshis, Pakistanis etc are being singled out and attacked. This is wrong. Period. Even if you bring food into your comuter class. And the attacks are getting more brazen and more frequent.
Till a few days ago Australian authorities were in denial, if anyone saw the Australian commissioner's interview and discussion session on NDTV on Sunday, 7th June, you would see that he was in denial. On the 9th finally the Australian Govt. made some statements, admitting a problem. But the TV achor was absolutly impotent, not asking the pointed questions as they do when they imterview BJP and affiliated organisations. There was no attempt or interest to put the Aussie into a spot, which was very much possible.
Again on the 9th, the Australian Commissioner was interviewed by BBC in the news and he said that the attacks were more in the poorer areas. Have not quoted adverbatim, but his statement was to that effect. That itself is no justification, and the Aussies could increase police activities in those areas which they consider poorer.
Then we saw our new foreign minister making a statement on TV. Oh, soooo weak, no wonder no one takes Indian politicians seriously. We have no strong personalities to take a tough stand. Appearance and a strong voice are very much required.
Then there is the usual syndrome, it has a name but I forgot, where we first we want to find our own fault for getting bashed up. Certainly there are reasons for which many themselves are responsible, but first one has to stop it and then look into the problem. Thereafter certainly look for corrective action. This should be handled like in a family: feuding among themselves, but when an outsider comes then present him with a united front.
So a good step seen was the unity among the students in protesting and hanging around in groups for safety in numbers. Retaliatory attacks are not the answer. I wonder if any of the Australian friends on this forum can say whether the Australian police have asked the students if they could indentify any culpits and nab them. Are these attacks being investigated at all? Seen nothing in the news over here about any arrests being madde. Just asking to know.
Yes, tourists also do get into difficulties in India, but it is more by way of an exception than a trend. Goa had a few isolated cases, but the locals were not the only ones to be blamed. If the Russians are worried, what about the number of Indian student who have been attacked over there?
There is a big problem of attitude as well. Many Australians are boorish, like at Simon & Co. On the other hand, our Desi's do have an attitude too, too loud, and a particular community is very guilty of this. But that does not justify these attacks. These attacks are against persons, civility does not permit and the Australian Government must come out strongly against this. The authorities do not appear to have done much so far, but Australian friends can tell us more.
Finally, Desi behaviour abroad is a problem, but that should be a separate thread where useful suggestions could be put up to help our Desi's. Many have gone there to study for the first time and somehow probably did not find the need to brush up on culture, behaviour and manners.
Once the attacks stop, we discuss Desi culture problems.
While the attacks persist, let us debate. |