Quote:
Originally Posted by jyobeb I own a 99 Sienna. I feel no difference in the quality of sheet metal or in the thickness of the A pillar (Which actually calls for a whole new design and jigs)
The door thunks shut the same way and feels as solid as the Sienna.
I do not care either way for maruti or Fiat, but irrelevent banter which is inaacurate, is not done.
Also smileys such as seem to be a fad these days. |
I just gave my opinion of that particular peice from fiat. after driving and enjoying a Fiat 1.2 for 2 years, i went to RF motors with high hopes. i have been waiting for the MJD for years and I was let down. what do i gain by bashing a company and car that I love so much?
the A pillar is definitely thinner. that explains the markedly improved forward visibilty from my older 1.2 palio.
Quote:
Originally Posted by condor @ripper, that was a nice way to compare the three cars. But I'll take most of what you have said with a pinch of salt. Reason : your disclaimer.
You have ended up comparing a car that you are comfortable with (atleast currently) with two others that you expereinced a TD on. And like you have said, using a TD car to get a feel of the car is a bad idea. |
I agree whole heartedly condor!
but the thing is, the indica does everything as well as the FIAT, except giving feel and fun, but it is still run down by members in our forum. that is not fair.
Quote:
Originally Posted by PatienceWins @rippergo: We are just sharing our opinions in this wonderful forum and opinions do differ. I will be the last person to give death threat for sharing opinions of a car. Its afterall just a car. |
I know PW, just trying to lighten the mood. dont want to make any enemies here.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ajay_J @Ripper, Good job. I too believe that now INDICA is emerging as a VFM winner. And V3 is going to kill all the debates. Amen.
@ET, I do not think that Swift's steering lacks feedback. It infact gives excellent feedback. But its more of video game like response hence mistaken as "lacking feedback" by the people graduating from HPS to EPS. |
True-it does give a videogame kind of feel. some people like it, somepeople dont. but the bottom line is, it tell you what the car is upto.
Quote:
Originally Posted by extreme_torque You are contracdicting yourself!
So a Palio steering is better than many sedans but not better than Swift... So can we conclude Swift has a better steering than most cars, this side BMW maybe.
Good on ya mate.... enjoy! |
I'm not contradicting myself,I said, Swift>Palio>some sedans(my verna for example)
Quote:
Originally Posted by prabuddhadg About steering, I have driven the Swift at 100, and on a slightly undulating road it felt pretty vague and scary. On that same road, my Petra does not even remind me of the quality of the road. It is quite possible that some people can handle the Swift's steering and prefer that to the heavy feel of the Palio/Petra steering, but I just can't let the nice Palio steering feel be relegated against the Swift's. My opinion. |
Prabuddha, thats the point.
on an undulating, poor surface, you are meant to be scared. the swift is letting you know whats happening. the palio isnt.
However both of them will hold the road well. its just that the swift is more talkative than the palio.(my opinion)
Quote:
Originally Posted by supremeBaleno Nice comparo and pretty fair too IMO, rippergeo.
Ofcourse, there is the possibility of a little bias creeping in, due to your owning the Swift, but then who can claim to be unbiased here ?
Only one question : Your comparo has the Swift and the Palio scoring on most of the factors, but in the end, you say that the Indica is the most VFM. If you were in the market today with these 3 choices available, would your buy be the Indica-Dicor ? |
I'd still buy the swift D because it is fun.
but if I was looking at a practical buy, It would be the indica.
Quote:
Originally Posted by MADMAX111 I agree with ripper regarding build quality of Palio. I have driven my friend's Palio1.2 earlier(2003 model) and recently test driven Palio MJD. The MJD build quality is definetly lower in terms of sheet metal etc and except outside looks I did not find the car outstanding in any aspect.
I think my views are unbiased as I dont own either Palio, Swift or Indica. I left Swift out of my buying decision due to less sapce at rear and tinny metal and rattles. Was opting for Palio but the TD definetly ruled it out. Like I said earlier Nothing Outstanding except looks. |
thanks for backing me up, madmax.
i never said the palio MJD is bad. just that the competition is better.
even its older avatars are better. that is worrying.
Quote:
Originally Posted by prabuddhadg You know what, we Fiat owners went ahead and bought our Fiats in the face of such opposition that we feel we are the real car enthusiasts and others who drive mainstream cars are not enthusiasts like we are.
So, we feel, (and to some extent we are right) that people do not really know the worth of our Fiats. So, given a hint of an opportunity, we wax eloquent about how wonderful our cars are.
Honest, this is how my mind works. And I am not being at all sarcastic. |
I'm one of them too.atleast I was.
I picked up the 1st Fiat 1.2 in cochin when it was launched, even without a TD. thats how much of a believer i was.
now i find it increasingly difficult to defend FIAT.
before I get an infraction for turning a simple TD thread into a comparo bloodbath, I'll stop.
No more comparos on this thread from me. I'm willing to take it elsewhere though.