Quote:
Originally Posted by speed-demon According to the company guy, palio will return a mileage of 17-18kmpl on city roads and 20-22kmpl on highway. which we should assume as 16kmpl in city and 19-20kmpl on highway. |
From my Multijet, I have got a mileage of 15.5 kmpl (in the usual terrible Delhi traffic) with AC on 80-90% of the time from my first tankful to tankful calculation before First Service.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Slick .....This reflects the attitude of the dealershios for both these models. My brother liked the skoda immensely for its looks, Build quality, interiors, image and the drive quality.
But the FIAT factor steps in and everything goes astray.
PS: The interiors, as mentioned earlier in the forum are poor but considering the price at which the car is being offered cant complain either.
(Both figs are approximate, onroad Mumbai)
Needless to say my brother is buying the Fabia. The turning factor though was the stories he has heard about Service and the first hand experience we got.... |
Well, we can't compare the Fabia and the Palio because of Sheer Pricing. Regards Service, it is a problem and I was fully aware of that while buying. Previous posts on this thread by me and their responses have discussed that in detail.
While it is natural to compare this car to the Swift DDIS, just check the equipment level of a SDE and the LDi (both 5 lacs OTR in Delhi). Personally I find Maruti's features-variant-pricing strategy a bit too much. I think a tachometer is an absolute necessity in all cars and especially diesels (ducking for cover). The basest Indica Xeta without AC has a tacho!
Quote:
Originally Posted by shibujp
However my test drive did not leave me with a good impression.
My gripes were as follows:
- cheap interiors.
- good engine but a very heavy clutch. After the light one in the Swift Vdi this felt like an exercise for your calf muscles.
- when using the clutch my shoes kept getting stuck in the footwell. Might be cos i wear size 10 but the Swift doesn't have such a problem.
- the gear shift as a result was not easy to use and I alway got the feeling that I had not depressed the clutch enough leading to tentative shifts.
- Refinement was not a patch on the Swift and the cabin became positively boomy when you revved up
- Somehow the engine felt quite stressed when revving up as opposed to that of the swift.
- Seating comfort seemed fine as did the boot space which is better than the Swift. |
Interiors: Dated and not so great in finish, if that is what you mean by cheap. Correct. But I find the ergonomics spot on... I am an architect-interior designer, I can appreciate the difference between a comfortable interior and a good looking one. But again, comfort is a matter of personal preference.
Heavy Clutch: Maybe. haven't driven the DDIS extensively. Have got used to it. Gearshift is a couple of generations ahead of WagonR, Alto, Indica as per my judgement and experience.
Footwell Size: At size 8 shoes, no issues. Will ask somebody with larger feet to TD. Dead pedal is comfortable. Pedal placement is such that I place my right heel on the floor. The right foot can easily tackle both accelerator and brake by a simple movement of the toes, without lifting my foot (because they are so close). Maybe it helps in heel and toe but I have never practised that except in the Ambassador days when handbrake used to be inaccessible!
Engine feels Stressed at higher RPMs: Don't agree. Have broken my self imposed limit of 2000 RPM once or twice and it runs very freely... like an unleashed beast. Once turbo kicks in, Engine comes into its element. Have no experience of beyond 2700-2800 rpm, but goes upto 3000 rpm quite well. If it its going at 90 kph on 2500 rpm in fifth gear, then why would anybody rev it in the region of 3500-4800 rpm (that's the redline) in normal usage except on the expressways while doing 120-130 kph?
Seating comfort / boot space: I agree totally. The pricing and the space had settled the issue for me. I know the Indica is more spacious by measurement, but I have done 1000s of kms on all seats of the Indica all over North Indian cities and highways, and I think Indica seats have poorly designed cushioning. Palio seats are much better with great underthigh support which many sedans lack as well.
All said, a comfortable, big, heavy hatch with a big turning radius and not so nicely finished interiors. Now that sounds a bit like a Tata
, doesn't it?