Being passionate about automobiles and having a restricted budget for your first car can be quite painful! However, after a lot of deliberation I realised that it could only be big hatch for me! The list obviously narrowed down to the Swift, Getz, U-Va and the Palio (largely because of 4.5 lakh budget). I will not bore you with the long story of endless research and near-agony (mental largely) over the choice of the Palio Stile Multijet, but here I am writing this after 4 days and 200 kms of owning the Palio...
This is my first car but I have been driving (irregularly) for the last 12-13 years. Being a serious biker, though, I appreciate ride, handling and the fact that a powerful and comfortable puts a driver in a better position to drive safer and better! Now about the car....
Exteriors: Subjective topic. The Palio is a handsomely proportioned car and also utilises the larger external size efficiently to give more space inside, very much like the Getz and U-Va and unlike the Swift. Fit and finish are acceptable and maybe just a notch below its competitors.
Interiors: If you consider space, seating comfort and ergonomics, this is the car. One of the major reasons for me buying this car was the fact that this was the first car I felt totally comfortable sitting in. All other cars, especially the Hyundais didn't somehow get the correct geometry between the back, the posterior and the pedals. Quality of finishes is not as good as the others (being an Architect and Interior Designer, I would note that more than others, i guess). If you want a car that looks and feels great inside, this is not the one. Joints are somewhat poorly finished and plastics look strong and durable but downmarket. For me, ergonomics is more important. Each to his own.
Performance and Efficiency: Too early to comment, but I am trying to keep the revs below 2100-2400 rpm for the first 1000 km. The manual or any other source does not mention what is the max engine speed during running-in. I am typically downshifting at 1000 rpm and upshifting at 2000 rpm. That also means that I can't really enjoy the turbo "kick" which comes largely after 2000 rpm.
Would request for informed opinion about the max rpm during running-in period from other members. In Delhi with the speed limit at 50 kph (and me broke after buying the car) I am driving in 4th gear most of the time but have tried 90 kph once at about 2400 rpm in fifth (I think!). Sorry for all the rpm talk, but being an old Pulsar rider, I end up watching the tacho more than the speedo!
After about 220 kms, the fuel tank has gone just below 3/4 full. Out of 47 litres, that should be about 12-15 litres so a mileage of about 15 kpl. But I am not sure till I fill up again! So I am not committing to that. The AC has been on at a max blower speed of "2" for about 30-40% of the time.
Since the first 100 Multijets including mine have an imported engine and gearbox, I find them smooth and precise. Though I think this engine is noisier than the diesel Swift and the gearbox doesn't go "khat-khat" like the Swift but its still generations ahead of the vague, rubbery WagonR and the Indica gearshifts. I have driven my friends Indigo DICOR a lot and I would definitely rate both engine and gearbox much higher.
Ride and Handling: I am a sedate driver and with my first car I am more careful. But I love the steering feedback! Power Steering feels heavier than other cars at Parking Speeds (some people used to driving Altos have told me "Power Steering nahin hai kya?"), but I am fine with that, because high speed steering feel is much better than the Getz. The Palios ride and handling quality does not need description and its still as good. I can take potholes like an SUVs and corners faster than I could on other small cars, so that's that.
One problem is the size. I am still getting used to twice the number of maneouvres required for parking as against my sister's Alto! Rear visibility is bad due to the C-pillars and the A-pillars hamper the "around the corner" visibility. A lot of reversing is by guesswork and the feeling that its a very strong sheet metal body!
However I have faced the same issues with the Swift which is worse in this regard. And the Swift bulges near the wheel arches making it more scratch-prone. But I suppose a good driver could easliy tackle all that. I am not that experienced so for me, its still an issue.
Ownership experience, Dealer behaviour and ASS: To be fair to the much criticised Fiat dealerships, there haven't been any major hitches except three:
1. The dealer staff know next to nothing about the car! I could educate them. They don't have any accessories ready because this car is not selling! No seat covers (with a biege colour, seat covers are important), no Central locking (to keep the warranty, only one Autocop model is valid, apparently) and worse, no left side ORVM (mine is the SDE.) So no accessories except a flimsy looking gear lock which locks only at Neutral! The don't even offer you water to drink in the showroom! No comparision with Maruti or Hyundai or any others, I guess. But, they got the car in a week (for the Swift would have to wait for 2-3 months), just as they had promised! No delays or lies to the customer. Poor Service but no sugar-coated dishonesty so far!
2. They mis-spelt my name on the RTO registration.
They have promised to fix it but I am still worried. It's frustrating at times.
3. The left side indicator does not self-cancel! The service staff said its a minor problem and can be fixed by "adjusting" a "ring" inside the steering column when I go for first service. But when you ride a bike, you always remember to switch off the indicators, so I am not finding it so difficult.
I have heard so many horror stories of Fiat service that I am keeping my fingers crossed! Lets see!
Summing up: In the end, it was the same old question by everyone: Why Palio and why not Swift or Getz? Why diesel when you only drive 1000-1200 kms a month?
I believe one should know ones priorities. I love driving and I appreciate driving comfort, as opposed to just seating comfort of, let's say the Accent or the City. I wanted a robust car which is good on the highways. I know ABS and Airbags are important, but I would also want more important passive safety like good build quality. Ergonomics are important but interior finishes are not top priority. After riding a Pulsar for 40,000 kms I have come to appreciate Ride and Handling as very, very important. I have also learnt how to keep a bigger safety margin. Hence the Palio Multijet! I have gambled on the Service Support, but then you don't get everything!
Why Diesel? The Stile and Getz 1.1 are both underpowered and overpriced in my opinion and Test Drive analysis. The Swift VXi with ABS is exactly 5 lakhs on-road like my Palio SDE, but that and the Palio 1.6 is beyond my affordability of running costs. I stretched my budget by 50 k which has pushed up my EMI. The Swift VDi is atleast 60,000 more than my Palio SDE.
So far so good. I am worried about the Service and Parts problems, but everytime I hit a pothole at 60 kph and get a muted thud, it seems worth it and much, much more!
More updates after 1000 km and First Service!