Re: Bodybuilding - Exercises and Supplements Quote:
Originally Posted by nilanjanray And why would you do that? Pull up is a compound exercise, people have been doing it for thousands of years. I can understand you had a bad experience, but if done properly, wide grip pull ups are a fantastic exercise. FYI, the greatest heavyweight MMA fighter in the world - who weighs ~ 105 kgs - used to swear by pullups, including kipping ones. And he is one guy who knows all about functional strength, without losing speed or mobility. |
Well, I did write quite a bit to explain that it's absolutely in my opinion and experience - and that's years and years now (maybe since 1995). And sure the MMA guys do it, the Crossfit guys and girls do it too. IMO you do what works for you, not just because everyone/someone else is doing it. Just for reference, there are many professional bodybuilders who don't and sometimes cannot, owing to their bodyweight and size. Dorian Yates for one, was a big proponent of the Pulldown Machine as against the Pull-Up; but I don't think he advocated Squats either - and that's a different story.
Coming to why I personally don't advise anymore; and I used to do them fairly properly, for years; - well it's all about Plane/Angle Of Motion for me. In Chest and Back I try work on all angles, so for e.g. Chest - Incline, Flat, Decline Press angles; top to bottom. And similarly for Back - Pulldown, Face Pull, Inverted/Seated Rows, Bentover Rows, Dumbbell Rows; again from top to bottom. Muscle activation is all in the plane/angle of attack, and in this design I find the Pullup a bit challenged in recruiting the Lats to their fullest ROM (range of motion).
The most recruitment of Lats I feel happens in the palms facing chin-up, or the close grip pulldown and the stiff-arm pulldown or pullover. And even gymnasts use rings for all pullup training movements, so as to adapt for individual physiology and do very little bar work, because the bar presents a very rigid framework.
So in my conclusion, the wide-grip pullup is a fantastic looking exercise only. It places undue stress on the shoulder assembly and the cervical region. I have made dramatic changes to my back and overall strength with just palms facing grip, and that can be wide or close grip for attacking at different angles and width.
Hope that helps, but if pullups work for you then plz carry on.  |