Re: The Cricket Thread Why Bangladesh is the worst team ever in Test Cricket
The dust is yet to settle on the paddy field of a Mirpur pitch. The memes of an entire slip cordon juggling around a catch, only to drop it is still doing the rounds of facebook feeds. For a side which never really took to test cricket even after playing the format for 25 years, the familiarity with the playing conditions at home was the only advantage they could count on. Even that is ebbing away for Bangladesh, after being thrashed in the two tests by the visiting Lankans. The home side could not even last a hundred overs, both innings combined, in their own backyard where two visiting batsmen helped themselves to consecutive tons in each innings. The writing has been on the wall for a while and hurtful as it may be for Bangladesh cricket fans, the team can safely be branded as the worst side ever to have played test cricket.
Sample some of the stats - after being given the right to play test cricket, Bangladesh (BD) has featured in 144 test matches, winning only 19, eight of which have come against fellow minnows Zimbabwe, which itself hardly plays test matches now. BD is yet to win its first test match against leading sides such as India, Pakistan and South Africa. While they have solitary wins against England and Australia, both have come at Mirpur, the graveyard of cricket pitches where the ball rarely rises above the knee. What is perhaps the most galling is the fact that in the 28 tests the nation has played against Sri Lanka, the most against any opposition, BD have won only one test match so far, only one!!! Contrast that with Sri Lanka, who have played 318 tests so far against all opposition, winning an impressive 105 of them. While the Lankans started playing tests almost two decades before Bangladesh did, test fixtures for the tiny island nation were few in the early days and more importantly, the islanders have a 2-0 series sweep in South Africa in 2019, which even their big brothers India and Pakistan have not achieved. That is remarkable by any standards, more so considering that both nations have an equally long cricketing heritage and a huge population disparity: 22 million for the Lankans to the 170 million of Bangladesh. Sri Lanka have produced some real titans of tests such as Muralitharan, the highest wicket taker of all time or Kumara Sangakkara and Mahela Jayawardena, both with 10,000+ runs at an average of 50 plus. In comparison, the only two Bangladeshi batsmen who I would call world class are Shakib Al Hasan and Tamim Iqbal, both still light years away from ten thousand test runs with an average not even in the 40s. Shakib is the only cricketer from BD who could have walked into any test XI during his prime. But the fact that he has played only 67 test matches during a career spanning 17 years and counting is an eye opener on the importance BD attaches to test cricket. Other test nations will play against you only if the quality of your eleven is up to scratch. But it is hard to make a case for BD who were beaten at home by Afghanistan in 2019, a side which had won test status only a year before! So what has gone wrong with the side which promised so much, but has only flattered to deceive?
Domestic Structure
On paper, Bangladesh's structure isn't very different from that of its neighbors. The National Cricket League has 8 districts competing in matches lasting 4 days and that, along with the Bangladesh Cricket League with its Duleep Trophy styled format, forms the core of its red ball league. In reality however, the gulf between first class cricket in BD and test cricket is wide with little spectator interest and a poor level of competition. Mominul Haque, the Bangladesh red ball specialist with over 4000 test runs, describes the difference between BD domestic and international cricket as 'night and day'. The test stars no longer even participate in domestic tournaments and teams play in front of empty stands in this competition now disparagingly dubbed as 'picnic cricket'. Poor quality tracks which make flat track bullies out of mediocre batsmen don't help either. According to an observer, there are few innings with 300+ totals in the BD domestic competition, which points to an inability of local batsmen to bat for long hours. Similar was also the picture in India's domestic competition before a revamp to make it more competitive, by preparing better pitches and streamlining the structure. That looks unlikely to happen in BD soon as players and spectators would rather have more of white ball cricket for reasons I am about to discuss.
Schizophrenic Support
Indian cricket followers are no strangers to the see-saw emotional turmoil that fans in the subcontinent experience. Having gone to the extent of attacking our TV set after an Indian defeat, I know what this is like. After many decades of cricket however and moving on from being no hopers to beating top sides in international cricket, the knee jerk fan reaction, at least in India, has stabilized in my opinion. This is far from the case in Bangladesh however where the fans, every bit as passionate and whimsical, go berserk after every win, even if it's against fellow minnows Zimbabwe. When the inevitable heavy defeat follows, they have no patience and just as easily abandon their allegiance. The opportunistic media preys on this and does all it can to fuel this mania. Instead of delving into valid cricketing reasons, the spotlight often turns to the off field activities of the players. The cycle continues until the next win. With Bangladesh becoming somewhat competitive in white ball cricket, especially at home, the average BD fan believes that limited overs cricket offers a better return on all the energy and emotion they invest in supporting the national squad. Red ball cricket however is a different proposition altogether for BD; the side will continue to remain hopeless in the foreseeable future.
Corruption
The BCB or the Bangladesh Cricket Board has come a long way from a dimly lit backroom office to the 5th richest cricket board in the world, ahead of even South Africa and NZ. As it happens, the money, instead of trickling down, has only encouraged corrupt politicians to grab their pound of flesh. Currently, Nazmul Hassan, a politician better known by his nickname Papon, calls the shots, much in the manner of a certain Kim Jong Un. Papon has no background or knowledge of cricket, yet he is now in charge of the most popular sport in a country of 170 million. His standard reaction after every defeat is to throw his team under the bus in front of the media, which he has done yet again after the latest series loss to Sri Lanka. Games in the domestic league are often mired in bad officiating and match fixing; a strike by top players in 2019 over poor pay threatened to blow the lid off this institutionalized match fixing in domestic cricket in BD. "We often know the result of a game even before the first ball is bowled", was Shakib's candid reply when asked for his reaction.
Lack Of Vision
As it happens, poor performance at the international level, a sustained one, can usually be traced to how talent is spotted and nurtured at the grassroots. With an underwhelming domestic structure, it is no surprise that there is no sub junior structure in place either in BD. Drawing a contrast again with Sri Lanka, which has a time tested school cricket circuit, where a Ranatunga or a Sangakkara was already making waves as a schoolboy, BD has no such system. That may not be a dealbreaker if you are a Pakistan, where a Wasim Akram went straight from playing tape ball street cricket to test matches, but that nation is an exception when it comes to raw talent. Moreover, with little vision for red ball cricket, there is hardly any exposure for the Bangladeshi second string or the A side. India for example, has a regular program for its A side which also includes red ball specialists, who tour Australia and England to gain invaluable experience of playing in alien conditions. In BD however, little has come of the promises made to players like Mominul, Taijul and others for overseas tours to develop their game. With the limited tests that BD play, these red ball specialists have no match practice between each test series when their teammates are off playing ODIs and T20s
As is the case with BD cricket, promises fly thick and fast when the nation is embarrassed on the cricket pitch. They are promptly forgotten when they whip Zimbabwe or Ireland again, to be trotted out when the next debacle comes around |