Quote:
Originally Posted by tbppjpr Which other companies are you talking about? Other phones hardly establish 5-10 connections which are mostly familiar connections like Google etc against around 40-50 unjustified connections established in a phone running MIUI ROM. This all happens when you don'r even setup your user account or enable MI cloud service.
And nobody accepts allegations so this guy's logic given in defense of his company aren't important.
If you are really concerned even little bit on this matter then please download some network tracing tool in your phone running MIUI and check yourself to believe whats really happening . Indian Air Force warns against using Xiaomi phones Chinese Smartphones a Security Threat, says Indian Air Force - Published: 19th Oct 2014
Taiwan has even started serious investigation against Xiaomi and considering imposing full ban on Xiaomi. |
TBPPJPR,
Those news articles do not get down to specifics. I am sorry but you need to get down to facts. Maybe I've missed something so feel free to point it out.
In about ten minutes of googling and about five pages of results, I have found only one clear report on this, all of which refer to this
IMA Mobile post. Here's one:
http://techtheday.com/chinese-manufa...tphone-spying/ http://www.financetwitter.com/2014/0...-block-it.html
Firstly, there's only one app in there that's connecting to a Chinese server. ONE. Maybe there's another report with those 40-50 connections but I couldn't find it.
Secondly, yes it is connecting to a ISP owned by a Chinese government entity - is that a spy agency network, or is it the equivalent of BSNL. I would reckon the latter. Here's how they
explained it - which seems reasonable to me.
Thirdly, this was July 31, 2014. They have since turned it off on
Aug 10th. And now their post, three months later says that any such cloud services will be moved to third party servers like Akamai / AWS. Your post does not have an up to date network tracing report!
Unless you have proof that their current softwares are still "stealing" user data *today* (rather post Aug 10th), I think we need to give the company the benefit of doubt.
OR run a diagnostic tool. Unfortunately I don't run MIUI on my phone at the moment else I would have gladly run it for you.
The only way to know the real truth is to run the networks tools on an up to date MI3 or Redmi 1S right now. Getting overly worked up basis either past information or an outright paranoia of China, is pointless.
Having said that, of course, I completely agree with IAF that they would like to ban. In matters of national security, no amount of paranoia is enough. For the rest of us, we need to assess it calmly and take a considered decision with
actual facts as of now.
Quote:
Originally Posted by tbppjpr Never seen if Samsung made available their TouchWiz ROM available for other phones or HTC put their ROM with 'Sense' interface on their website for free download and usage. |
This is incorrect. Please understand that no manufacturer encourages porting their ROMs, except folks like MIUI (maybe 1+?). Therefore you will not see official downloads of Sense/Touchwiz ROMs for other phones, but you WILL see Sense/Touchwiz ports for other phones.
Here you go:
Sense for MotoG,
Sense for SGS3 ,
Touchwiz for HTC oneX, etc.
Now MIUI is different. Just because it does things differently from other companies doesn't make it a criminal for God's sake!
In my understanding (feel free to correct me), the company doesn't sit and make ROMs for every device. But they gladly encourage porting of their ROMs to other devices. Here's
MIUI for i9300 - none of the ROMs worked for me though. What worked was a
user developed version which had a fatal mike mute bug so I don't use it anymore.
At the end of the day, I appreciate the honesty with which MI is engaging and I would like to give them a chance. Clearly you didn't even dissect Hugo's statement but rejected it outright, convinced of MI's wrongdoing. Unless you have fresh watertight proof of any (criminal) wrongdoing, we should avoid unnecessary negativity.
Please understand that the company is not run by a bunch of fanatical idiots - it does not take long for a well trained researcher to prove wrongdoing if it is actually stealing consumer data wholesale. Doing so will invite outright bans and kill the company. Why would they do it? Would you do it if you were the MI CEO?
PS: The above link:
http://www.financetwitter.com/2014/0...-block-it.html also mentions at the bottom how you can stop the data transmission after rooting! (maybe block all chinese IPs for good measure?

)