Was in office all day and used my phone for the forums. So couldn't write a proper reply to each one of you.
Quote:
Originally Posted by drsingh It seems you'll be sharing cars with the family.In that case it makes sense to buy a simple petrol for the commuting and spend more on the 12 L+ highway car your dad is planning to upgrade to. Its a good idea to have a small city petrol and a big highway diesel in a two car family. As your family holds on to cars for a longer period depreciation doesn't really come into the picture. Brio petrol is a good choice.So is the i20 if youre after features. As youre going to drive less,affordability is not a problem, buy any car that appeals to you. |
I would be sharing it only on a sunday if it's a diesel hatchback. If it's a petrol, then not. Well, I kinda agree with the small city petrol and big highway diesel in a two car family. I've seen the Indica + Safari days and boy wasn't it comfortable.
Quote:
Edit: Another option might be the new EcoSport diesel. Although it is not really going to be "fun to drive" in the purist kind of way. But it will serve with efficiency, commuting, highway runs, and resale value.
|
It serves everything, but it's slightly over my budget. We don't want two SUVs in the family. Don't want to pull out a giant even if I'm going out for buying milk.
Quote:
The 1.2l petrol is one of the most refined units around and real world fuel efficiency is 11-12kmpl.
|
My bad. I've been driving diesels all my life. I consider anything below 15 as "bad". Need to rethink about petrol efficiencies now.
Quote:
Another option is the Honda Brio. I am not a big fan of its looks or interiors but you may like it.
|
I'm also not a fan of the rear end or the interiors. But I've read that it's a peppy and fun to drive car. All my friends disagreed with the decision of even thinking about Brio.
Quote:
Originally Posted by diyguy I would just go with a Swift, new or second hand since it is a VFM car and both petrol and diesel have their pluses. I have a 2006 Zxi Swift and a 2000 Qualis GS myself. I was amazed when I got to drive the Swift diesel of a friend. Amazing pickup and terrific FE.
Maintenance of the petrol is very cheap too and I've driven my Zxi intercity as it has air bags and ABS. |
I don't really like the new Swifts looks. But I like the old one. I might as well start looking for a pre-worshipped one.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ghodlur Based on the requirements I would suggest a Wagon R since it suits you the best. Space wise, maintenance wise and fuel efficiency wise. Also its a tall boy design, will not be a problem during ingress/egress for your height. Quite a nimble city car. |
Even though a Wagon R suits my needs perfectly, my dad pretty much hates it. I don't know why.
Quote:
Originally Posted by saket77 Thorny shoes to be in! Anyway, I will suggest you only 2 cars from the lot:
1. Wagon-R: Easy on your bank, low maintenance cost, fuel efficient, good space for a tall guy like you, decent ergonomics, decent drive and good for city.
2. Fiat Punto: Very good car, matured road behaviour, good build quality, a great Diesel option to satisfy you dad's wish, and excellent safety, but outweighed in terms of service & maintenance costs by the other Maruti option.
Regards,
Saket |
Wagon - R : Dad hates it.
Fiat Punto: Again, I tried to convince him about looking at the Punto. He grumbled something about Fiat and made himself busy.
Quote:
Originally Posted by brraj Your situation screems for a used petrol hatchback as anyway you are planning to invest 12+lkhs on car in future.
by this
- No need to worry of depreciation.
- No need to worry of maintenance.
- No need to invest 7lkhs instead 3-4lkhs is more than enough.
Swift petrol zxi it is. |
Sometimes, you just need an affirmation.
Quote:
Originally Posted by bigben My suggestion would be either a Swift or a brio. Both are small and will be easy to maintain and besides if you are going to get a 12+ lakh car, it makes sense to go for a smaller one.
The brio being a Honda, you can be assured of peace of mind and good resale. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by comfortablynumb I'd suggest a test drive of the Ritz. Notwithstanding its quirky looks, am sure you will be pleasantly surprised by it. Considering your height, it'll be quite comfy w.r.t to ingress/egress too. |
Quirky Looks. Too quirky.
Quote:
Originally Posted by hellmet I initially thought you wanted to replace the Indica that you sold recently. However, on reading this quoted sentence, one thing comes to my mind. What will you do with three cars? Warning: Weird advice follows:
If I were you, I'd cut the budget by a 7th and get myself the most comfortable motorcycle possible and put the rest of the cash in my pocket.
If you're not much of a motorcycle guy, get an automatic scooter and enjoy your commute with the twist of your throttle.
40-50km per week is very little usage and a 2 wheeler could take you there in comfort most days of the year. Hell, I do 40km per day on my motorcycle, but I'm not saying you should.
No old car repair bills and wasted-time issue, no new car depreciation, and you'll always have a two wheeler for quick nearby puttering. |
Dad will sell off the Safari before he buys the next car. I've driven a Chetak for two years and a Pulsar 200 for the better part of my college days. I sold off my Pulsar when I moved out for my higher studies. Sometimes, I really regret my decision of selling it off. But I didn't want it to eat dust in the hostel. Sometimes you part away with things to preserve them!
Well, back to topic. I live in North India. Here's what the year is like:
Jan - Mar - Too cold
Apr - July - Too hot
July - September - Too much rain
October - December - Too cold
Don't want to bother my dad time and again every time it's raining. Also, my dad is pretty concerned about safety issues while riding a bike. So he's not comfortable with the idea of me riding a bike.
Thanks a lot for taking out the time and showing interest!
Cheers!