Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 | EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N

The Rainmaker · 20th December 2022, 07:59

Quote:

Originally Posted by souvikjana83

If by performance, you mean rapid acceleration from speed 0, then I would assume, you haven't driven an EV ever. In the EV all the torque is available from the start and if you floor the pedal, no turbo petrol, Diesel or turbo diesel can match the acceleration an EV will provide.

Check out the EVs for performance.

I appreciate your suggestion and for acceleration alone EVs are great but I'm a true petrolhead. Would never support an EV platform as long as I'm alive unless our corrupt netas force us to. Moreover, as I already mentioned EVs don't have manual gearboxes or hydraulic steering or the sound of an internal combustion engine or the flexibility of instant refuel and go. Somehow the idea of EVs doesn't sit well with me from any perspective.

You're right, I do value performance but not at the cost of analog feedback and raw feel of the car. For me performance includes acceleration, handling, shorter wheelbase, cornering, body roll, direct feedback from the steering, raw analog experienced, manual controls etc. which no EV or even a regular modern car offers. Hence my previous post

clevermax · 20th December 2022, 08:44

Mahindra folks, if you are reading this, fix the horn latency issue in the TBHP Car of the Year 2022.

https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/offic...ml#post5438454 (Mahindra Scorpio-N Review)

The horn starts sounding after a considerable delay after the driver presses the horn pad.

And, nobody can do a beep-beep (short quick chirps) with the Scorpio's horn. It will either not sound at all or will come out as a straight single chirp.

bsdbsd · 20th December 2022, 11:42

Great show all around! Good on T-BHP and Mahindra. Is it "discriminating" or "discerning"? Though I understand the context. Not sure why I am niticking but couldnt resisit.

GRAND23 · 20th December 2022, 12:15

May be Anand Mahindra's tweet and Team BHP Car of the year triggered Economic Times to publish this article today??

Anyway, this is simply astounding performance by Mahindra. Few years back people were talking about how not to buy Mahindra and TATA cars. But here it is, we are seeing the days about how to buy Mahindra and TATA cars.

Today, there cannot be one single customer who cannot have Mahindra and TATA car in their car buying options.

Kudos to the team who are investing their best efforts.

ZenMaster · 20th December 2022, 12:16

Mahindra's recent success has to be accredited to them finally figuring out and fully embracing what they truly are (the maker a true SUVs and UVs) and then working with a singular focus to become the best at what they are and make each of their vehicles, the best in their corresponding categories in the Indian market.

This is what happens when a company finally finds out its true calling and then gives 100% effort. Gone are times when they were wasting their time on experimental and quirky often nonsensical vehicles like quanto, kuv100 etc.

While Maruti's future plans might looked non sensical at times, no one is as good as them at at finding what the customer will accept. (Not necessarily what they want, but what the indian mass is willing to accept as the standard).
Maruti has mastered of the art of making perfectly average cars - and this is by design. While as enthusiasts it might not be exciting, its what's most Indians will be willing to buy with their eyes closed.

Bhodrolok · 20th December 2022, 12:32

We are a SUV nation so it's not surprising the Scorpio-N won, following the Thar last year and the XUV 700 the year before.

However I am just glad the Virtus & Slavia have a combined second highest tally of votes; although it maybe that everyone who actually like these cars are actually on Team BHP.

Ph03nix · 21st December 2022, 10:49

Quote:

Originally Posted by Venkatesh

Team thanks Team-BHP

Attachment 2391366

Attachment 2391367

Did he mean discerning, instead of discriminating? Could be auto-correct, it is rather aggressive on iphones and not very accurate at all.

designatedriver · 21st December 2022, 11:42

They have Thar 5 door and XUV400 coming in 2023, I've a strong feeling one of them might take the next COTY award.

ranjitnair77 · 21st December 2022, 14:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ph03nix

Did he mean discerning, instead of discriminating? Could be auto-correct, it is rather aggressive on iphones and not very accurate at all.

Exactly my thought when I saw the tweet so I Googled the meaning. It means "having or showing refined taste or good judgement".

However no one really uses it that way anymore. Discerning would have been more appropriate.

RaiAnish · 21st December 2022, 18:30

I'm surprised looking at previous winners here - Zest and Maraazzo

RotBohnen · 30th December 2022, 14:12

I can't vote yet, but the Tiago eV would get my vote easily. Everything else seems to be in the 20L or more Segment. Having a proper usable eV from a legacy manufacturer who's invested completely into Electric is a great inroad to having EVs penetrate the regular market.

I'm hoping for an affordable Nano eV sooner than later.

View Poll Results: Which is YOUR car of 2022?
Maruti Alto K10	10	0.44%
Citroen C3	52	2.30%
Maruti Baleno	16	0.71%
Toyota Glanza	6	0.27%
Maruti Brezza	44	1.94%
Tata Tiago EV	275	12.15%
Kia Carens	93	4.11%
Skoda Slavia	142	6.27%
Volkswagen Virtus	207	9.15%
Maruti Grand Vitara	170	7.51%
Toyota Urban Cruiser Hyryder	299	13.21%
Mahindra Scorpio-N	632	27.93%
Hyundai Tucson	148	6.54%
Jeep Meridian	13	0.57%
Toyota Hilux	20	0.88%
BYD Atto 3	20	0.88%
Audi Q3	2	0.09%
Mini Cooper SE	3	0.13%
Mercedes-Benz C-Class	22	0.97%
Volvo XC40 Recharge	11	0.49%
Kia EV6	78	3.45%
Voters: 2263. You may not vote on this poll

20th December 2022, 08:44	#302
clevermax Senior - BHPian Join Date: Jun 2006 Location: Tvm/Amsterdam Posts: 2,112 Thanked: 2,897 Times View My Garage	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N Mahindra folks, if you are reading this, fix the horn latency issue in the TBHP Car of the Year 2022. https://www.team-bhp.com/forum/offic...ml#post5438454 (Mahindra Scorpio-N Review) The horn starts sounding after a considerable delay after the driver presses the horn pad. And, nobody can do a beep-beep (short quick chirps) with the Scorpio's horn. It will either not sound at all or will come out as a straight single chirp.
	(3) Thanks

20th December 2022, 11:42	#303
bsdbsd BHPian Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: Bangalore Posts: 501 Thanked: 504 Times	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N Great show all around! Good on T-BHP and Mahindra. Is it "discriminating" or "discerning"? Though I understand the context. Not sure why I am niticking but couldnt resisit.
	(8) Thanks

20th December 2022, 12:15	#304
GRAND23 BHPian Join Date: Sep 2013 Location: Bangalore Posts: 193 Thanked: 481 Times	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N May be Anand Mahindra's tweet and Team BHP Car of the year triggered Economic Times to publish this article today?? Anyway, this is simply astounding performance by Mahindra. Few years back people were talking about how not to buy Mahindra and TATA cars. But here it is, we are seeing the days about how to buy Mahindra and TATA cars. Today, there cannot be one single customer who cannot have Mahindra and TATA car in their car buying options. Kudos to the team who are investing their best efforts. Attached Thumbnails
	() Thanks

20th December 2022, 12:16	#305
ZenMaster BHPian Join Date: Mar 2019 Location: Kottayam Posts: 568 Thanked: 2,564 Times	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N Mahindra's recent success has to be accredited to them finally figuring out and fully embracing what they truly are (the maker a true SUVs and UVs) and then working with a singular focus to become the best at what they are and make each of their vehicles, the best in their corresponding categories in the Indian market. This is what happens when a company finally finds out its true calling and then gives 100% effort. Gone are times when they were wasting their time on experimental and quirky often nonsensical vehicles like quanto, kuv100 etc. While Maruti's future plans might looked non sensical at times, no one is as good as them at at finding what the customer will accept. (Not necessarily what they want, but what the indian mass is willing to accept as the standard). Maruti has mastered of the art of making perfectly average cars - and this is by design. While as enthusiasts it might not be exciting, its what's most Indians will be willing to buy with their eyes closed.
	(2) Thanks

20th December 2022, 12:32	#306
Bhodrolok BHPian Join Date: Apr 2015 Location: Bangalore Posts: 659 Thanked: 1,651 Times	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N We are a SUV nation so it's not surprising the Scorpio-N won, following the Thar last year and the XUV 700 the year before. However I am just glad the Virtus & Slavia have a combined second highest tally of votes; although it maybe that everyone who actually like these cars are actually on Team BHP.
	(5) Thanks

21st December 2022, 11:42	#308
designatedriver Newbie Join Date: Sep 2022 Location: Gurugram Posts: 15 Thanked: 161 Times	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N They have Thar 5 door and XUV400 coming in 2023, I've a strong feeling one of them might take the next COTY award.
	(1) Thanks

21st December 2022, 18:30	#310
RaiAnish BHPian Join Date: Sep 2022 Location: New Delhi Posts: 77 Thanked: 278 Times	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N I'm surprised looking at previous winners here - Zest and Maraazzo
	(1) Thanks

30th December 2022, 14:12	#311
RotBohnen Newbie Join Date: Oct 2022 Location: Bangalore Posts: 7 Thanked: 15 Times	Re: Team-BHP Car of the Year, 2022 \| EDIT: It's the Scorpio-N I can't vote yet, but the Tiago eV would get my vote easily. Everything else seems to be in the 20L or more Segment. Having a proper usable eV from a legacy manufacturer who's invested completely into Electric is a great inroad to having EVs penetrate the regular market. I'm hoping for an affordable Nano eV sooner than later.
	() Thanks