Quote:
Originally Posted by Harbir Harish,
I am trying to understand the situation more clearly, but I get confused with all the posts on the subject so if you don't mind, I'd like to ask if I understand it correctly: - You car was in an accident
- Nummer Eins, the Skoda dealer, installed parts that were not official Skoda replacement parts, but charged you for Skoda parts.
- You discovered this and raised the issue with Skoda.
- Skoda had the parts replaced with official Skoda orginal equipment replacement parts.
- Skoda asked you to not procede against Nummer Eins and to let them deal with it.
- You agreed
- Skoda disenfranchised Nummer Eins, who is no longer a Skoda dealer.
- While this was going on, somebody from Nummer Eins tried to steal the non-Skoda OE parts that had been removed from your car
- Skoda wanted you to sign a letter by which you would take back your claim and be unable to make this claim in the future
- When you refused to do this, Skoda took the position that it could not be proved that those parts had been fitted to your car by its dealer and asked you to pay again for the parts, though you had already paid Nummer Eins for the parts when the car was originally repaired.
- Now Skoda refuses to return the car to and is looking like its trying to drag the case out to eternity, seemingly to prevent resolution that could possibly establish officially that its dealers do engage in fraud.
- Therefore, it seems like Skoda was willing to fix your problem but only if you cooperated in ensuring that Skoda dealers committing fraud does not get established a legal fact.
Is this correct?
If it is correct, and Nummer Eins was indeed disbarred, I think Skoda went very far indeed, further than I could imagine any company in India going. That would mean that they are serious about dealing with dealers committing fraud, but are also interested in protecting the standing of the Skoda and its dealer body.
In that case, I think we can atleast give Skoda credit for having taken such serious action against Nummer Eins, which is no small issue, and for having fixed your car.
That leaves the issue of you refusing to sign the letter they wanted you to. On one hand, if you sign that letter, it would amount to dropping your claim, and of destroying the reality of this action by the dealer. On the other hand, somebody could argue that Skoda took extreme actions in order to compromise with you but you chose not to compromise with Skoda.
To me it seems like if you choose not to compromise then Skoda has the choice to either accept on paper that its dealers commit fraud, or it can decided that it has made good faith efforts to resolve your issues, fired the fraud committing dealer, and since you are in return not willing to help them with what they need, they'll fight you in the courts and use the tools available to them to get what they want.
The website for Nummer Eins is non existent ( www.nummereins.co.in )and the registration for the their domain name expired about 2 weeks ago. if this dealer has gone out of business because of this fraud, or has had to start up as a different company doing other things, I think thats pretty extreme action by Skoda on this case and it makes me atleast somewhat sympathetic to their desire for some protection in return for having taken such extreme action on behalf of customers. |
Harbir - I would like to correct the sequence and add a few points.
Point no 1 to 4 and 11, 12 – absoulutely right.
I would like to go to point no.8, which is the crux of the issue –
8. It wasn’t anybody from Nummer Eins. It was Skoda Engineer Yogesh Vaidya under direct instructions from Head of Customer Care, Karthik Ramesh, who tried to smuggle the spurious parts out and tried to hand it over to Nummer Eins, and that too clandestinely, after I left the workshop. I had demanded they be handed over to the Police.
This was in May 2008, much before point no 5,6 and 7.
After that I had filed a Consumer case against Skoda and Nummer Eins on 17th July 2008.
Point no 5 - Skoda asked me not to proceed against Nummer Eins only with the Press. The case against them could continue.
Point no 6, 9 and 10 – absolutely right. This happened on 19th August 2008 at the JW Marriott, Mumbai.
Point no 7 – happened on 5th September 2008.
Please note that this fraud was discovered in April 2008. Skoda shut the dealer in September 2008. Skoda did not do it of their own free will. There was immense pressure put on Skoda though the Press, Television, Police, German Embassy, Indo German Chamber of Commerce, Czech Embassy, Volkswagen, affected customers etc. If Skoda had its way, they would have smuggled out the evidence, destroyed it and claimed that the parts removed from my car were genuine.
Credit to Skoda for having fixed my car?
No way Sir. Skoda dealer committed a theft in my car. Skoda is responsible for their dealer. I do not think Skoda did me any favor by rectifying my car.
This racket was on at Nummer Eins for a long time. Do you think it could flourish without the blessings of regulators at Skoda? The dealers were not the only ones to blame. There is a bigger angle to this whole story. Trust me, it is a Pandora’s box.
I would like to remind you that my accident took place because of the existence of spurious brake discs and pads in my car. I was lucky I was alone and not with my family. Skoda and its dealers are playing with the lives of Indian citizens and their families.
Yes, Harbir, I chose not to compromise with Skoda and Nummer Eins because if I would have, the next car that would have entered Nummer Eins after I left would have had the spurious parts installed in it. I believe serious action should be taken against the dealer and all those who facilitate him and they should be heavily penalized. I am not for accepting my car and brushing the whole thing under the carpet
After reading all the cases coming from various dealers, do you think, Skoda is seriously interested in protecting their standing?
Conclusion –
Despite Skoda people involved, I agreed to let Skoda off the hook.
I did not ask them to accept that their dealer committed fraud. Why should I accept that their dealer did not? Quote:
Originally Posted by harishv GTO.
I believe Nummer Eins has started a new venture with ex Skoda MD as partner, called
Roadworx ( Roadworx.in) is a aftermarket service center for high end imported cars.
It is promoted by One Stone International Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai in joint venture with Roadworks, Hamburg, Germany
The Directors are :
Imran Hassen (Ex-Skoda MD)
Ravneet S. Medi (NummerEins)
Frank Lischewsky (Roadworks, Germany)
H.S. Vijan (NummerEins) |
Figure out the nexus. Sacked dealer starts new venture with ex-MD of Skoda.