Quote:
Originally Posted by SilverSmoke Done with 46K KMs. No reliability issues whatsoever. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Old Dude I second Siversmoke - the Kodiaq doesn’t have any reliability issues - the DQ200 dry clutch DSG in the older Octavia and other cars were the one with known failure mode if the daily driving involves extensive bumper to bumper stop and go traffic.
Go for the Hycross if the usage involves regular use of the 3rd row seats |
Quote:
Originally Posted by phi My car is at around 14K km now, and running like new still. I got a parking camera controller failure in between, which was prompty replaced within warranty without any fuss. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by somersault I believe, I bought a 80% Q5 level vehicle at 55% of the Q5 cost. Even in the city like Mumbai, unknown people regularly come to me and admire the Skoda brand and the vehicle. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by SNOWY227 I want to know the reality you have faced with the Kodiaq. As in the regular service costs, any failures, or any issues with the DSG. |
It takes some mental preparation to purchase a Skoda in India. Be it the Slavia or the Kodiaq. As it is my third Skoda in last 14 years, I think I can safely say that things are looking better. When I owned a Laura TDI DSG, I was new to the community, I did not know about the possible drawbacks of the gearbox / reliability issues. Unfortunately that partnership ended prematurely when I was involved in an accident that totalled the car. So really, I did not get to the mark where reliability issues would start to creep in.
Then comes my Octavia which had been called a "lemon" many a times in the forum, especially my car because the way and frequency of issues that came up in that car. If I start elaborating, I'll need a holiday and a lot of tissue boxes. One thing is for sure, the Octy is by far my favourite car. I started appreciating it even more after getting my Kodiaq. The Octy has clocked over 195000 kms in 11 years of ownership. Yes, a lot of those miles were painful as and when the car broke down some times due to a major fault or sometimes something as minor as a failed battery. But the Octy has taught me a lot. Its made me aware of my environment and what kind of use / abuse I can give to my cars. I can sense and diagnose issues in the cars instantly. A serious skill which I am sure not all of us here want to learn but the petrolhead in me has matured with this car. So I went in whole heartedly for the Kodiaq for a number of reasons.
1) I wanted a bigger car for my growing family. Not that the Octy was small by any means, but intending to go for many road trips in the future I wanted an SUV and I wanted to replace my aging and problematic Octy.
2) The black interior of the Sportline bowled me over.
3) DSG is the supposedly more reliable DQ381. Now I have had one event on this, where the gearbox went in to emergency mode, but quickly turning the car off and on again got rid of the issue, and later a software reset and calibration meant things were back to normal. The issue hasn't cropped up in 12000 kms. My car is currently at 52K Kms. When I read on the international forums, DQ381 has an oil pressure pump, that can fail sometimes, and that is what causes the gearbox to enter emergency mode. But it is not a major issue.
4) After owning the Kodiaq, I felt more confident on the road. Having a Crysta at home, it was my go to car for long road trips. But once I got the Kodiaq, the Crysta only sees small intercity trips. I would always take the Kodiaq for any long journey thanks to its comfort, suspension, noise insulation, music system and ease of use. Power is not its strong point. It disappoints sometimes, especially when I go back to it after spending some time in the Octy.
So yes, you need to be mentally prepared and ready for anything if you buy a Skoda, no hiding the fact that problems can occur anytime. But the Hycross isn't immune to issues. Have seen various reports where there have been critical failures of the hybrid system causing people to be stranded on highways. I am sure just like any other OEM, Toyota would have already found a fix and applied the patch to all Hycrosses sold already. So I do not bother myself now with issues in cars. It's a machine, and a million parts, something will fail at some point.
You do need to be aware and patient. Aware so that you are observant and keep regular checks on your car like checking the oil and coolant levels, air pressures, oil leaks, battery health etc. If you identify an issue early on, the problem becomes much easier to solve. Till now, I have had only one major issue in the car when the steering column lock malfunctioned and that would mean I cannot turn on the ignition. But the problem was resolved under warranty in 4-5 days. The only issue was transporting a car that doesn't have ignition and hence no power steering. But we managed it with brute force to turn those 18" wheels and tyres. (thankfully steering lock was disengaged)
Summing it up with what all the others have mentioned above, I really appreciate that some of us here feel that they have purchased a car with much higher perceived value and quality. But I for one dont. I feel the interior on my 11 year old Octy is holding up 100 times better than my Kodiaq's. The quality of plastics is just cheaper and not as soft and luxurious as found in the Octy. Having said that, since you're competing with the Hycross, the story isn't any better. Plastics quality overall seems downgraded to Crysta owners. So it all comes down to use case. If your family is going to be happy with a stiff ride, non-usable 3rd row, abysmal fuel economy in city, slightly higher maintenance cost, then bring all your might together and roll on the floor to convince them for the Kodiaq.
I say higher maintenance costs because, it's not just service cost you have to look at. There is a cost to over all maintenance of the car which includes batteries (AGM battery is expensive to replace), insurance, tyres, brake pads, brake discs. Other items such as suspension top mounts, tie rods, suspension bushes, engine mounts, gearbox mounts, etc. All these will come up for replacement around 80K kms, or sooner due to wear and tear. These are not really cheap. I have been doing this on my Octy every 70K kms so I have already done it twice or thrice.
Another factor will be that the Kodiaq always has to run on RON95 fuel (XP95 from IOC) otherwise you are looking at a siezed engine and Skoda will not pass any warranty claims for wrong fuel filled in the car. This is critical and is a non-issue in the Hycross.
All the best and do let us know what is your final buy.