Hello
I drive a Honda City VX 4th gen facelift 2017 model and have always felt that the stock tyres were not of adequate width with 185/55/16 size. I also encountered 2 sidewall punctures due to potholes and that further compelled me towards the change.
The factory Bridgestone Ecopia tyres are meant for extracting the most mileage so comfort and minimising road noise are not their strong suit.
Low ground clearance also is a known fact about the City which damaged the Plastic engine splash guard. I once had to stop the car and get it repaired during a trip as it started to touch and drag on the road. Ultimately had to get it adjusted and fixed properly at a Honda dealership with a few clips and screws.
Both these issues nagged me whenever I planned to go any long trips so I finally decided to upsize the tyres.
Researched a lot on team-bhp and finally decided on Yokohama Earth-1 195/60/16 with the stock rims. The tyre shop owner initially refused to install the size as he was sure that on turning full lock of steering, the tires would touch but I insisted and after installing both the fronts we took a test drive and it was all good. The owner of the shop was surprised to say the least. What I learned was that aftermarket rims are an issue with this upsize but stock Alloys don’t pose any problem, at least that’s what the shop owner said. I have always liked the stock alloys a lot so never changed.
Now I know that the difference in circumference is 5% and that it’s more than the recommended 2% but I feel in my case it
solves all the issues.
1. The ground clearance has increased and I know that for sure because the car doesn’t scrape on places it did before.
2. Because of the increased sidewall, the ride quality has improved a lot and has given me peace of mind when accidentally carrying more speed over potholes.
3. Wider section makes the car more stable at triple digit speeds. I feel195 should have been the default size from the factory.
4. Yokohamas have also made the cabin a lot more quiet - NVH has improved dramatically.
When I first drove the car after the upgrade, I couldn’t believe that all these improvements were instant and happening just with a tyre change. I initially thought there might be some placebo effect involved but such was not the case - every single person that sat in the car after that change instantly expressed the plushier ride and “cloud like feeling over bad road imperfections ” They could see the bumps but not feel them.
I was delighted.
5. And the most unexpected or rather unplanned advantage is that now the speedometer reads the actual speed (factory speedometer reads about 5-10% more than the vehicle’s speed for safety regulations) I have verified this using gps speed from my phone and also from the speed traps that are setup to display speed on highways.
Now coming to the
not so good part
1. The odometer reads 5% less distance - I knew it was going to happen so wasn’t a surprise. The only change is that I have stopped looking at the odometer to quote distances.
2. Mileage has gone down but not by a lot
Earlier used to get 17.x in the cluster but afterwards I have seen the highest in the 16.x range only.
Now it’s just a speculation but because of odo error maybe the mileage is not dropped by what it shows as the car is covering more distance on same fuel but to the computer it’s the distance is decreased by 5% - so the display shows less milage because it’s calculated as Km/L. I have not verified it by tank to tank method.
What I basically want to say is that the benefits outweigh the drop in milage by a lot and it’s not even a concern.
I made the tyre changes in August 2022. That car had then ran around 35K km
Now the Odo reads around 49K so I have driven these tyres close to 15k. All the advantages hold true till date and I am very pleased with the upgrade. Never had any puncture during this time. All I can think is why I didn’t upgrade the tyres earlier.
Because of the increased sidewall, the tyres fill the arches properly and give the car a better stance - an impression that the car is lowered. In my eyes the chunkier sidewall and filled up arches make my car look better too - a little bit sports car like.
The day I got them installed
Present day
Costing -
Shop - Tyre Point, 21 Old Arjun Nagar, Delhi (
https://maps.app.goo.gl/xTm8yVN9yeJkLPncA?g_st=ic)
Owner is polite. Would recommend the place. Authorised seller of Yokohama.
I replaced all 5 tyres including the spare as the City comes with a proper size alloy.
Make sure to check for the date of manufacture of the tyre - mine were 3022 which means 30th week of 2022 that is 25-31 July. So less than a month old(installed in August 2022)
Rate ₹7,400 per tyre - total ₹37,000 for 5.
The original tyres had ran 35K and 2 of them had punctures - both sidewall but I got one repaired professionally and had kept that as the spare tyre.
The shop accepted all 5 at ₹5,000
Got a message from Yokohama acknowledging the purchase and warranty.
Got balancing and alignment done for free. Only cost of weights was charged.
Total cost - ₹32,000
Hope this was helpful!