Quote:
Originally Posted by Anandg Hi Mods,
I am not sure if this tread exists, in case if it does, please delete this one.
I would like T-Bhpians to post their views on safest car on indian roads but with following things in mind:
1) This query is for all Noveu Richy (does it points to IT people ) guys who have just learned driving or have money but not sure which car to purchase that is safe (at least from car's perspective).
2) Car should be under 10Lakhs as this is where maximum purchase happens. Also high end cars have anyways all features but one should have money to own and maintain them.
3) The views should be on both hatchback and Sedans.
4) The car should be good looking, should have some bells and whistles, is fun to drive and as well as has good safety features. (no amby's here).
5) Car should have good manners on both city and highway.
6) They should not cost a bomb to repair for their safety service (at least not for small damages).
This is requested so that people who are looking for new cars but consider safety first, get an honest opinion about which cars can be their life savers. |
You can make this a poll, where people can vote for safest car. But going through the entire thread looks like the title is a misnomer. What appears is that you are looking for is a safe car which is VFM. Is that true?
But if you are looking at safest car I guess it has to be i20. Its only car below 10L having curtain airbags. Has got 5 star NCAP rating. Make no mistake I am no fan of i20 or Hyundai. Quote:
Originally Posted by McLaren Rulez Hyundai i20 probably. IIRC, its the only one with six airbags in your price range. |
Completely agree. Quote:
Originally Posted by McLaren Rulez This may happen in any car. Certain types of impacts do not activate the airbags. For instance, hitting a pole in most cars may not activate the airbag and almost all user manuals admit to this.
I might also add that being heavy or having that European thud doesn't necessarily mean safer. This rather old discussion has some valid points. | Quote:
Originally Posted by sandygordon One doubt
Is it just the tank like build that determines safety?
Japaneese and Korean cars rely on crumple zones in their feather-light cars for addressing safety issues. Finally its the percentage of impact that is transmitted to the occupants that determines how safe the car is.
I feel any car with airbags and ABS in this category(sub-ten laks) is equally safe, because there is no other tech in these cars like the merc or beemer to keep the occupants safe.
I feel the i20 full option or swift zxi is equally safe as a fabia or a linea/punto. |
Thats true. Quote:
Originally Posted by vikrantj Sedans : Linea
Hatches : Punto
Small hatch : Spark
Having 6 airbags does make one feel safe, but that is not the deciding factor for a car's safety. I would rather base a car's safety on following points not in order of precedence.
1. ABS
2. Braking Distance.
3. Build quality (steel thickness etc)
4. Airbag
5. Drivability / Steering feedback.
Rgds
Vikrant |
Vikrant, no offence to you, but steel thickness is not a criteria. I have always heard people saying that old cars (to that matter bikes) used thick metal and hence safer. Nowadays, cars are designed in a way that in case of a front collision their bonnet part (including engine and all) should crumple. Its designed to take away most of the impact force and should transmit the least impact force to the passengers. So in laymen terms it is supposed to act as a shock absorber for the passengers in case of collision. So that the car might be destroyed but the passengers are safe. That is what @sandygordon meant and is I guess one of the deciding factors Quote:
Originally Posted by noopster At the risk of sounding pompous, to a large extent how safe you are in teh car depends on your driving practices and commonsense. If you drive defensively and avoid risky situations, while ensuring that your car is well maintained in the brakes, tyres and engine department, any car is as safe or unsafe as the other. Features like ABS, airbags etc. will certainly help in case something goes wrong- despite your best intentions, something can and WILL go wrong!- but they are no guarantee of safety. So I would stop obsessing over this and go with my heart!
Swift Zxi or Vdi with ABS? The Vdi has an excellent diesel engine and ABS- go for it! |
My friend, being safe definitely will depend on how you drive, but thats not how we can measure cars for their safety. For that we need to see how the car behaves under adverse situations. We need to look at various crash tests, safety equipments etc for that. Yes handling of the car will have an impact but only in avoiding accidents. What happens in case of an accident is a totally different thing and thats what the safety feature of the car determine. |