Quote:
Originally Posted by shyamg28 Hey Neil! Are you recommending textile for additional protection it offers? Or cool weather protection? Or both?
I think if it's protection primarily, it still makes sense & I can reconsider. |
shyamg28, in the Indian motorcycling community, there still is a lot of confusion on what a mesh jacket is and what a textile jacket is. Hence, enthusiasts are not able to discern the benefits of one, as compared to the other. Before I answer your question, let me take a step back to the basics. That will help clarify things for you and others like you, who have the same doubts.
A mesh jacket, by its very definition, will predominantly have mesh as part of its construction. Mesh sections allow in a lot more air than a thicker material. These mesh jackets are typically lightweight. In almost all cases, a mesh jacket offers lower abrasion resistance than a textile jacket.
A textile jacket, on the other hand, will predominantly have stronger, heavier material as part of its construction. These sections allow in a lot less air than a mesh jacket. These textile jackets are typically heavier than mesh jackets. In almost all cases, a textile jacket offers higher abrasion resistance than a mesh jacket.
In India, we have to consider the fact most riders use their bikes for commuting, weekend riding, touring etc. If you can have only one jacket, a mesh jacket makes sense. When it rains, put a rain liner on top. When its winter, wear a thermal liner inside etc.
However, that doesnt make a textile jacket useless in India.
In the city, you will be moving at slow speeds and need maximum airflow to keep your body cool. A mesh jacket does that very well.
On the highways, you will be moving at high speeds and do not need maximum airflow for 8 hours a day. You need to control the airflow.
This is why, mesh jackets have fixed and large mesh sections. On the other hand, textile jackets, come with pockets and flaps at the front and back, to control airflow.
Why is all of this important? Let me explain with two examples.
Assume you are going out on a night drive through MG Road. The weather is good and you have some nice music playing in your car. This is the perfect situation to roll down your windows and enjoy the cool breeze as you head down an empty Brigade Road.
Now, assume you have to drive from Bangalore to Madras, instead. Same weather. Same climate. Would you want to drive those 4 hours with the windows down? You wouldnt, because its too much airflow at much higher speeds.
Also, keep in mind that you are typically getting much better abrasion resistance and hence, better safety with a textile jacket. If you are going to be riding at 120 kmph on a highway and you have to have a small fall, would you rather you were wearing a mesh jacket or a textile jacket? The latter, obviously.
Quote:
Originally Posted by neil.jericho Please dont consider getting a mesh jacket for touring, more so since you already procured the Explorer V2 jacket. All that airflow is counterproductive for long days on the saddle. The Klim Induction is a mesh jacket. That said, the Induction would be a terrific jacket for commuting usage. |
Quote:
Originally Posted by neil.jericho Hence, I prefer and recommend jackets which allow you to control your airflow (which means no fixed mesh patches in the jacket which cannot be closed) and which have separate liners (above / inside is individual preference). You should really consider the Royal Enfield Nirvik and the Revit Sand 4 H20 as your next jacket for touring. |
Hence my statements above.
Do go through some of the very useful posts from other veteran tourers on this thread, to get more insights into why a textile jacket is needed for touring.
Quote:
Originally Posted by shyamg28 I have done a fair bit on mesh jackets alone, both south & north India. And find that even mesh can get decently hot haha! This, despite a base layer.
What starts to irritate after say, half a day's of riding with another half left, can be how the jacket sticks or feels when wearing it.
This is where I feel, something like a Klim Induction will help, even in stickiest of weather. |
The Klim Induction will change nothing about your experience, since its another mesh jacket with the same form factor. All that you will get is much improved abrasion resistance and hence better safety. You will still be equally irritated after the same half day riding, with the same stickiness.
Quote:
Originally Posted by shyamg28 My ultimate intention is, one should want to wear the gear. Not have it be an irritant over a long ride  |
A decision to wear riding gear is a state of mind ! It has nothing to do with mesh, textile or leather jackets
