Re: The English Movies Thread (No Spoilers Please) Dune Part Two - my two cents, for what it's worth.
What makes a movie epic? Is it scale? Is it complexity? Is it a story that is both fantastic and believable? Is it characters that are both heroic and flawed? Is it the music? Is it economy in storytelling despite multiple strands and a complex plot? Is it cinematography that's sweeping and grand? Or is it production design that's detailed and lush?
I would think that it's a combination of all of these. Come to think of it, all the movies that are considered epics including The Ten Commandments, GWTW, Ben Hur, Lawrence of Arabia, et al tick all the boxes above.
However, all these movies are now decades old and belong to the golden age of Hollywood.
In recent times, there really haven't been that many movies that could be called epic in terms of design and execution, except maybe Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings trilogy. Until now.
Dune 2 is the epic that we have been waiting for all this while. Denis Villeneuve's direction combined with Hans Zimmers' soaring bagpipes laden score, outstanding performances (especially Javier Bardem's), lush and imaginative cinematography (by Greig Fraser), incredibly detailed production design (Patrice Vermette), not to mention an adapted screenplay that makes a complex story easy to follow and understand, makes Dune 2 a spectacle that is both enthralling and astounding in equal measure. Many of the circumstances shown are thought provoking and topical to boot, and resonate with the world we see around us. While the first film was excellent in itself, it was more of an entree and Dune 2 is the main course.
It is almost superhuman how Villeneuve has pulled off the movie, with a narrative that keeps things simple and easily comprehensible, despite the complexity of the source material and the many strands running in parallel and also crisscrossing throughout the movie. Viewers will find many parallels with another series of books - Game of Thrones, but what GOT's TV adaptation achieved over 8 seasons and a decade (and that too with an underwhelming final season), Dune 2 achieves in less than 3 hours, and with far superior quality and impact.
Like a true epic, Dune 2 follows the journey and coming of age of the lead, while at the same time making telling commentary on race, colonialism, religion and power (both the abuse that stems from it and the love of it). Characters are grey but their motivations are clearly stated and seem to make sense too, which makes it hard to hate (or love) anyone, including the protagonist. It is not an accident that the protagonist is a messianic figure who like other such messianic figures across different epics and actual history grows into his role and embraces it reluctantly while being self-serving all the while despite claiming to be motivated by other altruistic objectives like freeing their people from oppressors.
The movie ticks all the other boxes and some of the sequences are thrilling and jaw-dropping. The only criticism is that it could have been a bit shorter and the pacing in the second half could have been better (which is why I didn't mention editing as one of the plus points), but for a movie that accomplishes so much and gets so much right, this is just nitpicking.
It is unfortunate that Dune 2 has released after the Oscar shortlist has been declared, else it would have been a shoo-in for multiple Oscar nominations this year (direction, visual effects, score, adapted screenplay, supporting actor, cinematography). Maybe it will get there next year, though movies released towards the beginning of the year of an Oscar season typically lose out due to recency bias.
On a different note, the more movies of Denis Villeneuve I see, the more impressed I am with him as a director. This is the second sequel that he has hit out of the park. And like Blade Runner 2049, which is undoubtedly the most apt sequel that a seminal film and personal sci-fi favourite like Blade Runner could have got, you need to watch Dune and Dune 2 back to back to fully appreciate the genius at work (not too difficult with Dune on Netflix and Dune 2 in theaters now). The other reason to see them back to back is that with both sequels the story picks up exactly where the earlier film left off and no clues or back stories are provided for the benefit of viewers who haven't seen the first movie.
As Dune 2 is epic in scale, it makes sense to see it on the biggest possible screen and I would recommend seeing it in theaters (preferably in IMAX) and not wait for it to come to OTT.
Villeneuve closes Dune 2 on a cliffhanger, and I am waiting with bated breath for the inevitable sequel, considering Anya Taylor-Joy just had one scene in the entire movie.
Bring on Dune 3!
Last edited by Neversaygbye : 8th March 2024 at 00:31.
|