Quote:
Originally Posted by navin I dont think the the 12" Sumoku subs I heard had class D amps but I did not ask Mr. Palesha that question. My attention was occupied by the BOOM and I was trying to figure out how much of that BOOM should be attributed to the install and how much to the subwoofer itself. The subs themselves were rigidly built and looked sturdy.
Like I said before Mr. Palesha did promise that he would introduce better sounding subs in the future and it could very well be that these are the subs you have heard. However I am very conservative in giving recomendations and in categorically rubbishing any product. I can recommend only those products where I have had CONSISTENT good expereince and Rubbish only those where I have had CONSISTENT bad expereince. Even so if you read my earlier posts you wil notice that I have not categorically rubbished Sumoku and have mentioned that the subs I heard were about a year old.
Also the second time I heard the Sumoku (Home Theater) subwoofers I had just come from a room that had Quads via a room that had a pair of Manger Zerobox 109. So every "BOOM" made me flinch more! :-) |
I never acussed you of categorical rubbishing, and never even intended the same. My apologies if you felt so. All that I was trying to do is to isolate and dump aside other products (and obviously their BOOM factor!) from our discussions and focus on the concerned product instead (and may be other better ones), rather than diverting too much into the company itself, its founder etc.
Quote:
As far as VFM goes I'd rather invest the 10-11K in slightly larger speakers (Home audio) and for 11K one can get a 3K Sony 552 amp and a 8K JBL 12" box that might offer as good if not better sound.
|
Thanks for your valuable suggestions, not only this one but also for the combination mentioned in other thread.
However, I still have a question-
wouldn't it be wise to vouch for additional advantages of classD for the same money? As per my understanding, classD has inherent advantages of very high efficiency and damping factor as compared to conventional AB or A class. The only downside is THD. But it has evolved over time and any well designed classD should have acceptable THD figure. I think anything less than 1% should be considered quite good , and more so for subs since ears are more tolerant in that range. Anything below that should not have much of practical significance. Moreover, THD is
amp only figure, generally specified (even for high end amps) when it is connected to a resistive load. But when it gets connected to actual speaker, damping factor also matters a lot since it is one of the important factor which determines accuracy of actual
sound. Since it is relatively difficult to achieve for conventional amps, some subs use -ve feedback systems (servos). With classD, higher damping factor => tighter, faster bass from any given sub. exact value of THD should take a back seat as long as it is below acceptable limit.
Is my understanding correct?
As a matter of fact, many low to medium range systems have already adopted classD and high end is following the trend. While their high efficiency would reduce load on battery in case of cars and other battery operated applications, it makes sense even in home as it will make power supply design easier. Looks like in near future it may very well defy thumb rules like heavy amps = better quality, reduce size of big-3 wires in cars and nullify need of cooling fans, big heat sinks and external amps (there was a discussion in some thread about panasonic releasing high powerd head units!). Apart from "power" factor, high damping factor, phase accuracy shall take on the SQ challenge.
Quote:
Lastly almost everyone is using China as a manufacturing center so it is not the "made in China" label that affects my judgement but the quality of the engineering. I do believe that Mr. Palesha is interested in making better subs and speakers. After all it is men like him and Rajiv "Cream" Dsouza (Lithos), Anandya Mukherjee (Sonodyne), Shyam Bajaj (Norge), Prashant Damle (Pandam), Damodar and Manas Ratha (Peerless etc..) and their peers who will push audio to the Indian masses. Ajay Shirke (Cadence) and Sushil Anand (Nova) etc. cater to a much smaller audience.
|
"china" part was not at all directed towards you! It was for those who would make undue fun of chinese names by calling them tomatos and potatos and what not. And also for those who may not be aware of chinese components used inside their "branded" products. That said, I neither have any special attachment to these brands nor do I get hurt by the mockery
Quote:
I forget to mention our very own B&T, Sam K (when he is not cavorting with the ladies), Gunbir/JB (autophile), etc..
|
Definitely, I hope to learn from their knowledge and experience. In case they launch their own products I would be more than happy to be their potential customer
