BHPian
Join Date: Jun 2005 Location: bangalore
Posts: 290
Thanked: 388 Times
| re: Next-gen Suzuki Baleno (YRA) unveiled. EDIT: Now launched at Rs. 4.99 lakhs Quote:
Originally Posted by thatsdileep MS is still going with the same old 1.3 L Diesel mill. Of course its the proven engine that has been powering pretty much all their diesel cars but when they are trying to step up the ante by offering this one as a premium car thru Nexa, they should atleast offer the 1.6L option. I don't think this 1.3L mill can compete with 1.5L engines from Honda, VW, Ford (Figo) unless it undergoes some serious bit of tuning. Especially with SHVS all they are looking for is the FE and not the performance. Of course it might still sell in the range 3-4k units a month with the MS badge. |
One doesn't have to come up with a new engine for the sake of it. If the existing engine is faithful and can be tuned, re-tuned to produce equivalent or more power with better fuel efficiency then I don't understand why anyone would just plonk a 1.5 engine for the heck of it. People who are buying cars based sheerly on cubic capacity are really old school IMHO. Where would Ecoboost 1.0L OR 1.2 TSI engine be in that way.
Also, using engine across many models if possible keeps the overall costs down, what doesn't work is one pays 10+Lakhs and doesn't expect to be overtaken by a Swift (which is silly if you ask me!). And that is the only
reason I see why a POLO TSI engine is not offered across the range.
I was just imagining what would run in the mind of all those VW/Audi customers wherein the same engine is employed all over and what would happen to BMW i8 when it is carrying puny engine but producing mighty power for the price tag of multi crore?
For example:- 1.9 TDI has the following applications according to Wikipedia
Of course with different state of tunes. Quote: Audi 8L A3 (Mk1) (AHU: 09/96-08/00, AHF: 01/97-04/02, ALH: 08/97-06/01, ASV: 09/99-06/01), Audi B4 80 (1Z: 09/91-07/95), Audi Cabriolet (1Z: 07/95-07/96, AHU: 07/96-08/00), Audi B5 A4 (1Z: 01/95-07/96, AFN: 02/96-07/99, AHU: 08/96-06/00, AHH: 04/97-09/01, AVG: 08/99-06/00), Audi C4 A6 (1Z: 07/94-06/96, AHU: 07/96-10/97), Audi C5 A6 (AFN: 04/97-04/01, AVG: 08/99-10/00)Ford Galaxy Mk1SEAT Ibiza Mk2 (1Z: 07/96-12/96, AHU: 12/96-06/99, AFN: 03/97-06/99, ASV: 03/99-05/02, AGR: 04/99-05/02, ALH: 10/99-05/02), SEAT Córdoba Mk1 (1Z: 07/96-12/96, AHU: 12/96-06/99, AFN: 03/97-06/99, ASV: 03/99-08/02, AGR: 04/99-08/02, ALH: 10/99-05/01), SEAT León 1M (Mk1) (ASV: 10/99-10/05, AGR/AHF: 11/99-09/02, ALH: 05/00-10/05), SEAT Toledo Мк1-Mk2 (1Z: 04/95-12/96, AHU: 06/96-03/99, AFN: 12/96-03/99, ALH: 03/99-07/04, AGR: 04/99-09/02, AHF: 10/98-09/02, ASV: 10/99-07/04), SEAT Alhambra (1Z: 03/96-07/96, AHU: 07/96-02/00, AFN/AVG: 09/97-02/00)Škoda Octavia 1U (Mk1) (AGR: 10/96->, AHF: 08/97->, ALH/ASV: 08/00->)Volkswagen Polo Mk3 Classic / Variant (AHU: 01/97-08/99, ALE: 11/97-08/99, AFN: 06/98-08/99, AGR/ALH/ASV: 10/99-09/01), Volkswagen Golf Mk3 (1Z: 07/93-07/96, AFN: 02/96-08/99, AHU: 07/96-06/00), VW Vento/Jetta Mk3 (1Z: 07/93-07/96, AFN: 02/96-12/97, ALE: 01/97-12/97, AHU: 08/96->), Volkswagen Golf Mk4 (ALE: 05/96-12/01, AHF: 10/97-05/06, AGR/ALH: 10/97->, ASV: 05/00-05/06), VW Bora/Jetta Mk4 (AHF/ALH: 09/98-05/05, AGR: 10/98-05/05, ALH: 11/98->, ASV: 05/00-05/05), Volkswagen New Beetle (ALH: 01/98-06/04), VW Passat B4 (1Z: 10/93-12/96), VW Passat B5 (AFN: 03/96-08/99, AHU: 08/96-08/00, AHH: 05/98-08/00, AVG: 08/99-08/00), Volkswagen Sharan (1Z: 09/95-07/96, AHU: 08/96-10/00, AFN: 12/96-07/99), Volkswagen Caddy (1Z: 10/96-03/97, AHU: 10/96-09/00, ALE: 09/97-09/00, ALH: 09/00-06/03)
|
So one needs to step back and see if it is really required to change the engine for the heck of it, if it is trust worthy and proving good in power and efficiency. I would think otherwise. If you are looking for an enthusiast option then I agree one should wait for Maruti to come up with the downsized 1.6L. But not for competing in the market for sure, they seem to be doing pretty well with the 1.3 MJD itself. Infact they seem to be running circles around everyone else, and with the new Baleno I expect them mostly do that to i20 as well.
Last edited by WRXXX : 20th September 2015 at 14:32.
|