Quote:
Originally Posted by v12 That was a wonderful trip Avi! Good to see that you are enjoying the Versys to the fullest. 4000 kms already you're putting in more miles than you did in the Bonnie. Since you have ridden both the bikes extensively, Would be good to have a comparison on the Bonnie vs Versys. |
Allen, Sorry for keeping you waiting for so long. Here is a simple comparison of both :
Kawasaki Versys 650 vs. Triumph Bonneville SE Prelude :
This post might look out of place and some may even feel it is unwarranted but, a thought to share something on these lines have been on back of my mind for a while now and it's but natural for anybody to compare the motorcycle they have owned especially if they are "similarly" powered. Also, since I owned both these motorcycles (Triumph Bonneville SE & Kawasaki Versys 650) for a good amount of time and more importantly have clocked reasonably good enough miles on it to be able to tell the difference
Therefore, please treat this feedback as purely an owner's view-point and nothing more than that. I love both motorcycles equally and if I was nuttier than I'm already with money to spare then both these motorcycles would be adorning my garage and be happy forever without any haunting thoughts for upgrades
Styling :
Bonneville is a beautiful looking retro-styled motorcycle with right amount of chrome and overall subtlety that adds to it's understated looks. For most non-motorcycle loving Indian population, sadly it's just a glorified bullet.
Whereas, Versys is styled for a purpose and it's tall stance with new changes to its cosmetic looks from 2015 model onwards looks wonderful and fully integrated into the Kawasaki family.
Versys adventure styling is you either love it or hate it!
Engine Note :
Bonneville's engine note is usually referred to as "Sewing Machine" sound but, I have to confess that after using Arrow performance exhausts the stock engine note is to die for. It has a nice gurgling sound that makes you aware of a powerful motor underneath.
Versys's engine sound is muted and almost commuter motorcycle'ish and has a indistinct characteristic sound of a parallel twin engine
Engine Performance :
Bonneville's engine is smooth but, not as smooth as Versys and has loads of low-end torque and power is literally on tap and feels wonderful in almost all gears. Highlight of the Bonnie's engine is it's wonderful low-end torque which is addictive and is evident from the fact that Bonnie makes much higher torque at lower RPM despite it making at least 10-12 BHP lower than the Versys
Versys low-end torque is a bit dismal (it's not instantaneous like the Bonnie's) but, it's mid-range and high-end performance is noteworthy. Even though the Versys comes in power much earlier than the Ninja 650 due to newer tune to the engine and from 3000rpm onwards until 10,000rpm this bike feels very powerful. The engine is so butter smooth that you can literally caress the sound (i.e you will be hard pressed to know if it's running when in motion)
Suspension :
Bonnie's suspension is on stiffer side and it cannot tackle bad roads with aplomb and most of the jars from the road can be easily felt.
Stiffer suspension coupled with front nose-dives which makes a "Thak" sound when it falls into a pot-hole/ditch that makes a sickening sound is heart breaking whenever it happens (and, it happens a lot; even when crossing speed breakers or front wheel lands in a small'sh pot-hole)
Versys suspension on other hand is in a different league altogether due to it's much advanced technology and full adjustable suspension wherein you can adjust the preloads on the fly.
The front never nose-dives and you can practically throw the bike into any type of bad roads and it just glides over them as if the bad roads do not exist. Infact, many times you feel like increasing speeds on bad roads due to the comfort that you feel when riding on them.
This is highlight of Versys !!!
Handling :
Bought both these motorcycles instantly after a test ride and primary reason for choosing them was their "simplicity" to ride and manageable power. I personally believe that 70BHP-90BHP is the ideal power range for our country that we can put it to proper use. Anything below or above might be too less or too much to handle
I had bought the Bonnie because of the simple way it rode and I had instantly connected with it and was a revelation how it handled (since I was coming from a bullet where handling is a non-existent subject akin to most Harley's you take corners in a wide sweep and hope you and you're tyres are still connected to the road

)
After that lovely handling experience of Bonnie, when I rode the Versys for first time I was taken aback as it handles much better than the Bonnie. It feels way to lighter than Bonnie even though Bonnie was just 10kgs heavier.
You can approach corners in a much more aggressive manner than the Bonnie and due to the styling i feel more confident to lean much further into a corner and literally feels weightless in corners. I'm able to practically "hang-out" of the bike and lean into corners which I wasn't that comfortable with the Bonnie. Overall feels of Versys is super nimble when taking corners. Whereas, due to Bonnie's lower height you tend to get little more cautious when taking the turns and cannot afford that carefree style you use in Versys as the additional weight of Bonnie also gets quite apparent
Brakes:
Bonnie's brakes were outstanding. Especially the front had so much bite that it was the single most reason to push the bike beyond it's means. But, due to non-ABS availability the bike would skid at the smallest hint of gravel and I had plenty of scary moments where I would skid and slide and would bring the bike back in line with corrections
Versys brakes during the initial days was not impressive as I was expecting Bonnie like instant bite but, Versys brakes are progressive and over the time (after 1500-2000kms) the brakes feel excellent and have "almost" the same bite as Bonnie's brakes.
But, where Versys scores over Bonnie, I never had even a single moment of "skid" in the last 6000+ kms despite me pushing the bike as much as my skill level allows me too. I would attribute this entirely to the availability of
"ABS" on the bike
Wind-Protection :
Bonnie being a naked motorcycle feels great until 150kmph but, beyond that speed it gets extremely windy and you will need a good wind-protection
Versys comes with an excellent stock windscreen that is easily adjustable and is perfect for riders under 5.9 but, for everyone else who are taller the stock screen provides decent protection but, for high-speeds it's recommended to install an aftermarket screen like Puig which will completely eliminate the wind at all speeds (including at speeds close to it's top speed)
Heating Issue in City Riding :
Bonneville during the first 1000kms used to get really hot and your inner legs would get scorched during city riding conditions but, the heat reduced significantly post the initial 1000kms. However, it never completely vanished, an underlying heat can always be felt whenever you are riding in bumper to bumper traffic.
Versys on the other hand manages the heat in some miraculous manner as there is absolutely no heat emanating from the engine. I mean not even a whiff during bumper to bumper situation. Either Kawasaki managed to deflect the heat into some of the front fairings or due to lower engine capacity or it might be a combination of both
Here is one motorcycle with a higher engine capacity
(865cc) with lower power figures vs. lower engine capacity
(650cc) with higher power figures. Isn't the world coming to the same situation where even cars are trying to extract maximum power from lower capacity engines (
for e.g the lovely CLA 45 AMG which has a mind boggling output of 381 HP from a 2 liter engine..Haha!)
Tyres :
Bonnie was shod with Metzlers which had phenomenal grip on-tarmac but, the moment it goes into gravel the story is different and would slide out too easy and too often
Versys tyres are almost exactly same as Metzelers. V comes with Dunlops and they too offer equally outstanding grip and gives you plenty confidence to take fast corners but, the front slides out too easily when even in the lightest off-road conditions. But, being a sports tourer, I personally feel Kawasaki made an excellent choice of tyres and I'm extremely happy with these tyres.
But, for all other folks who are serious about using their Versys off-road then a dual purpose knobby tyres would be very helpful (might choose that whenever I'm due for tyre change)
Summary
When I relocated back to India, my immediate thought was to buy the Bonnie again but, the then news of impending launch of globally renowned Versys 650 stopped me from buying it and I have to thank my impatient stars for keeping me at bay to make this fantastic decision. Both these motorcycles are outstanding in their own aspect and would be happiest if I could afford to have both of them in my garage so I can enjoy best of both worlds
Let me not be the usual diplomatic reviewer who does not want to give a straight answer, if you look into my eyes and pop the question
" Which is a better motorcycle?"
My answer without blinking even once would be the
"Kawasaki Versys 650"
I tried to share my feedback on above being as forthcoming and honest as possible without getting biased towards any one motorcycle.
Hope you enjoyed reading the comparison and if you have any queries, happy to answer 'em !!!
Cheers
Mobike008