Quote:
Originally Posted by apachelongbow I agree!! However buying something like the Innova, for resale value, and compromising big time on driving pleasure IMO is not the hallmark of an enthusiast, but of a person who considers a car as an appliance like a mixer or a fridge. |
"hallmark of an enthusiast"
. Besides owning a car that gives driving pleasure what are the other criteria that would certify a person to be an enthusiast or is this the only one?
with you to a certain extent that people who buy utility vehicles (especially MUVs) see more value in their utility than anything else. Now if you want to compare this to the utility of appliances like a mixer or a fridge, so be it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by pgsagar You stole words from my mouth. I am surprised to see some teambhpians owning Innovas. I thought Teambhp is an enthusiasts' forum. Shouldn't we rather be discussing Fortuners, Scorpios, Safaris, Captivas rather than Innovas, Xylos, Taveras, Sumos etc.? Latter cars are plain taxis. What fun do people get driving these delivery van like people movers? Innova may be more reliable and may have a T badge. Other than that, I see no difference between Innova and Tavera or Xylo. They are all taxis. As you have rightly said only a person who thinks of a car like a utility product like a washing machine would buy these cars. |
My dear friend, psagar, I am sorry to say, but I am feeling quite offended with this statement. Do you mean that, TBHPians should never buy an Innova or if a person has an Innova, he cannot be a TBHP member and Innova owner's cannot be enthusiasts?
Do people drive a car only for fun and nothing else? I would be greatly appreciate if you can show at least some respect for other people's choices. Each person has his own reason to buy a car and without understanding that just making fun of other people's choices, ain't mature enough.
Quote:
Originally Posted by TorqueyTechie Team BHP is and will always be a forum for all likeminded individuals who want to learn and share their experiences, knowledge and passion about their vehicles.
All people buy car (or a bike) depending on their families needs first and later think about performance and other aspects. Saying that people driving Innovas and the like are not enthusiasts or bought by people who treat a vehicle as a commodity is pure blasphemy! |
Well said, TorqueyTechie. +100 to that. People buy cars that serve most of their needs if not all. If I was a lone person or at max family of two, I would opt for a two seater, sports car and not a people mover. If I am a family of 6 or 7, I won't even look at hatches or sedans. Given a choice everyone would like to have a hot, sporty car for self indulgence and a people mover/ SUV to take the family out, but how may of us have the luxury of owning two or more cars?
Quote:
Originally Posted by Storme_on_d_way We dont buy a car out of our enthusiasm everytime. Sometimes, we need to look beyond the sporty image, higher bhps and go-anywhere abilities and buy it keeping the family needs in mind. I just found your over-enthusiasm a bit offensive for people who invest in those so called 'taxis'. I thought its about a team of people connected by a common love known as Bhp and even tata nano has it. Just my two cents. No hard feelings |
You have hit the nail on its head Storme_on_d_way. Making fun of other people's choices and getting sadistic pleasure from that can't be a TBHPians virtue. I was very happy with my hatch, the Tata Indica for 10.5 long years as it was serving my purpose, but when my family grew to 6, I needed a bigger car. I always had a soft corner for the Tata's as someone has rightly said above that no other car manufacturer provides as much real estate as the Tata's do. So the Aria and the Storme were natural choices, but then they were too big for my apartments reserved parking. Hence I could not consider them. The Innova fitted in just perfectly and became my obvious choice.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Buffetfan The reason a car sells well is because it tops the charts in a few areas but is respectable in all. Before we happily bash the Innova as difficult to drive, noisy, underpowered etc lets spare a thought - if it was so bad, it would not sell in the numbers it does. |
Now if I add something to what you have already said Buffetfan, this thread may well drag into a Storme Vs Innova fight, which obviously I don't want to do. I respect the Storme for what it offers. The other day on my way to office, when I was following a Storme in my Innova, I realized that the Storme driver had such an imposing stance and I was sitting pretty low compared to the Storme driver.
Quote:
Originally Posted by apachelongbow If you and all the cabbies and other users get pleasure in spending hard earned money on bare basic rides, more power to you... |
Again my dear friend apachelongbow why so much hatred for other car owners? You can call me a cabbie driver all throughout my life, because for 10.5 long years I owned and drove an Indica, which is the darling of all cabbies and now an Innova, which incidentally happens to fall in the same category.
To tell you the truth, couple of months back I was supposed to attend one company get together over a lunch in the Hyatt hotel. Just as I entered the hotel porch and was about to get down from my car to give it for wallet parking a suited-booted sardarji tried to enter in my car assuming that this was his hired Innova. When I stared at him with a strange look, he realized his folly and expressed his apologies for barging into my personal car. For the rest of the day me and my friends couldn't stop laughing at this incident.
Quote:
Originally Posted by dhanushs Whoa.. hold your horses guys.
People buy cars suiting their needs. If you need a tractor at your farm, but, the enthusiast in you demands a Fortuner, can you do this?
Being an enthusiast doesn't mean, you cant buy a practical people mover if you need one. |
+100 to that dhanushs, I don't have any further comments on that, you said it all.