Quote:
Originally Posted by a_nan Take it for a test drive and you will get over all this.
It drives surprisingly well and the highway behaviour is very good with the crde version.
It's definitely overpriced, finished poorly, etc.. but they don't have any competition at all.
It's these days one really misses the father of the thar "dabhar behram". Was wondering how he would have replied to this..
Just go through all the threads Shankar.balan, it's probably the vehicle that has the maximum amount of discussion about it. |
Here's a reference review by Car Advice Australia - not too bad and not perhaps as uncomplimentary as I am being...but like they say, opinions are very subjective.
http://www.caradvice.com.au/416194/m...-drive-review/
And here is a copy paste comment from that review, just for perspective's sake...
"JHP • 7 months ago
they are charging $25k for a car with no radio, rubbish interior, appalling safety features and designs from the old jeep? i dont see a reason to buy this car, when you can get suzuki jimny with automatic transmission, better equipments and features, better safety, and great offroad capability for around $22k"
Now, as per your post, note that I have indeed gone through all the threads and have been doing so pretty much since the launch.
And Ive driven this Thar along with my father when it was launched. And I ve been a Mahindra user for years too - so have my family members. No longer though!
(My Dad also said exactly what Im saying here by the way..)
Saying that, whatever Mr Dhabhar may have replied, the following details are NOT to be ignored. However much we may like or revere someone, if the truth has to be told, then so be it! Fact is, the Thar is not upto the mark at all in this modern world.
Another thing, just because this vehicle may have the maximum amount of discussion about it, doesn't mean it is "God's Gift" to the paying public. The fact is that right now, there aint nuthin' quite like it which probably catalyses all these discussions amongst the enthusiastic off road community.
However, if the self same off road community were given the choice of a "Trail Rated" Jeep Wrangler Rubicon or Sahara or Unlimited at a fair and equitable price, do you really and honestly think that they would choose this Mahindra Thar over it? To my eyes, no way!
This is exactly the trouble with monopolies - they make these manufacturers complacent to the extreme - just like the protectionist economy Ambassador and Fiat manufacturers were, until Maruti came along and shook 'em up! Or like HMT was, until Titan came, saw, conquered and killed 'em off plus sowed salt on their god darned foundations!
What irks me severely is that these M&M folks have been making Jeep type things since the 1940's (1947 in fact when it was Mahindra and Mohammed...). And now, nearly 66 years later, we consumers are still being fobbed off by M&M with poor quality rubbish!
Yes the engine is good. As is the Borg Warner 4WD system.
But leaky roofs? Poor Ergonomics? Bad safety norms? Useless braking? Poor fit, finish and finesse? You may be willing to excuse these but I certainly am NOT going to.
I certainly won't endorse this vehicle as much as I would like to - essentially it is more or less the same as our old 1980's MM540's or 1990's MM550's with some few trashy bells and whistles thrown in here and there over the last 30 years! For Gods sake even that zig zag line in relief on the front doors is the same, as are the glass windows and winders and so on!
In the same timeline, the original Jeep chaps have completely revamped and developed the bare basic design of the original WW2 vehicle into a first class, safe lifestyle plus off road vehicle, which has plenty of finesse, safety and certainly doesn't suffer from leaky roofs!
Or take the case of Toyota and their FJ Cruiser. What a vehicle it is now! Compared with those old FJ Cruisers of early days!
Cant M&M have done perhaps 75% as much at least?
This is my personal opinion basis years and years of Jeeping about and creeping about in 4WD vehicles. Im sure some will agree and many may not, but that's really their affair!
(By the way, while I also absolutely love Gypsy's and indeed have owned two in my life so far, the same feedback as above, goes for those vehicles as well. Those blighters in Maruti ought long ago to have offered us the Jimny - but in 2016, 30 years after the Gypsy was introduced, they have seen fir to come in with the silly old Brezza which has a lot of bling and jazz but very little functionality by way of off road or 4WD etc...)
Grumble Grumble Rant Rant....thats all I can do really.
So like many others around, I ve gone off and gotten me-self an alternative in the form of the BigFoot SnowMonster which ticks many but not quite all, the boxes...