Hello,
The purpose of this post is to highlight the poor and unsafe quality of tires are supplied with car model Alcazar. I purchased a Hyundai Alcazar Petrol AT Signature model with registration date of 12-November-2022 from Shreem Hyundai, Prabhadevi Mumbai dealership.
It has not been even 60 days since the purchase and I have already had two major problems. On the day of the delivery, when driving the new car back home we noticed the AC was not working. It was blowing hot air after 5 minutes of working fine. After a few calls to the dealer, they registered a complaint. They sent someone from the workshop on 19 November (not sure of the date here) to check/confirm the problem. The technician, on driving the car, within 5 minutes the AC stopped working again and the problem was acknowledged. The car was taken to service centre where the problem was fixed - as per the email (see attached email screenshot) from service manager Mr. Ninad Manohar dated 23-November-2022, it was a faulty compressor valve that was replaced under warranty. It is heart wrenching to see a brand new car have such a quality issue on DAY 1 and the car has to be taken to the service centre with barely any kms on it.
I find it unacceptable that a brand new premium car costing Rs. 24 lakhs is not subject to proper quality checks and delivered to a customer in this state. This problem that presented itself within 5 minutes of driving should have been caught when the car was being driven from stockyard to showroom or from RTO to showroom but there was probably no mention of it by the driver to the dealership which I find surprising.
The second problem was more grave and could have been a major safety issue. The Alcazar Signature Petrol AT comes shod with
Apollo Apterra 215/55 R18 tires. These seem to be of inferior quality since two of the tires had a sidewall burst at relatively slow speed (50-60 kmph) when going over a rough patch of road on NH48 highway.
Timeline of what happened:
2-Jan-2023 6am: we left from Ankleshwar GIDC area on NH48
2-Jan-2023 6.40 am: we reached the Kamrej toll plaza
2-Jan-2023 6:40 am: the left front and rear tires burst barely 2kms from the toll plaza when going over a rough patch of road. There was NO pothole deep enough to cause this kind of damage, just a rough section. Many cars went through that section of the road unharmed. After our tires burst, the sensors beeped and the car pulled to the left. Luckily there was no trucks and we had just left the toll plaza so we weren’t doing highway speed otherwise it would have resulted in a major accident - I had my wife, son, a relative (78 years old) and his granddaughter in the car as well.
2-Jan-2023 7:30am: after trying to lower the Stepney in vain, I called the BlueLink helpline number following which they registered a complaint. They said I’ll get SMS of complaint number, but I never got any. They connected me to the roadside assistance team and took down details of the location and said a towing van is en route from Surat. It would reach in 60 minutes.
2-Jan-2023 8:40am: called the bluelink helpline again, gave the same details as before, they connected me to RSA team again, again they took the same details and said van has suffered a puncture and will take time. This time they said ETA is 90 minutes from 7.30 am.
2-Jan-2023 10am: Finally after getting calls from about 3 towing van operators, one finally came with a recovery truck on which they loaded the car with us onboard.
They took us to Navjivan Hyundai Body shop at Udana, Surat.
Note: They should have taken us to the service centre since this was a tire issue, not an accident case. But giving the towing operators benefit of doubt since this is what they’re probably trained to do.
From 10am - 5pm I was shuttling between the service centre and the body shop and various tire shops trying to find a shop that has this particular size of tire. All this while, my wife, 10 yr old son, 78 year old uncle and his granddaughter were waiting at the Navjivan Hyundai showroom, tired and exhausted while the dealer/service centre tried to arrange for a set of tires. At first they said they’ll call someone from Apollo for inspection. Nobody turned up and we didn’t want to waste time since we wanted to drive back to Mumbai the same day. At first they contacted their own dealerships to check for the tire. There were none available. They then contacted Shakti Tires - an independent tire vendor who said he has one Apollo 215/55 R18 available. When we went there and he removed the tires from the rims, he checked his stock and said it is 2021 model of tire which will not fit this model of car/rim. This was at 1pm. Report from Apollo tires claims this is not a manufacturing defect and cannot be considered for warranty (see pictures).
Between 1-4pm there was not much progress. It was me asking what is the situation and them telling me they are trying to find a vendor who has the tires of this size. Again, I don’t know much about tires, but they said we could have two of Apollo and two from another company but those had to be front and back matched.
Around 4pm they located a vendor who had GoodYear tires in the 215/55 R18 size available.
2-Jan-2023 5pm: Tire vendor came with 2 tires, I was driven in a demo car to the tire workshop at Adajan and the new tires were fit onto the two rims and wheel balancing was done. Then we came back to the body shop.
2-Jan-2023 5:30pm: the two wheels with new tires were fit to the car and we drove the Alcazar back to the KS Tires shop at Adajan to replace the remaining two tires as well.
I decided to replace all 4 tires with GoodYear since I have completely lost faith in the quality of these Apollo tires.
2-Jan-2023 6:30pm: All 4 tires were replaced with GoodYear tires. Wheel balancing and wheel alignment was done and we had to stay overnight at Surat since it had become dark to drive back to Mumbai.
Total bill came to Rs. 58,000 for the set of 4 tires + labour + alignment/balancing. There was no warranty either from Hyundai nor from Apollo to bear or even share this cost. This serious lapse in quality is again appalling for a trusted brand like Hyundai. Not sure if complaining or taking legal action is going to be of any use other than draining my time, money and energy further with nothing coming forth from Apollo or Hyundai.
I am certain I am not the only person to have reported such a problem with these tires.
In Summary,
What went well:
1. Shreem Hyundai was always responsive and supportive, promptly registered complaint, acknowledged the problem, sent the technician and got the issue rectified.
2. Navjivan Hyundai staff (Mr Nilesh, Mr Hitendra) were super helpful and constantly with me following up on the status of the tires.
3. Navjivan Hyundai staff (Mr. Srinath) stayed with me from morning till evening driving me around to various tire shops, waited with me till the four tires were replaced and wished me luck before heading off. Didn’t accept any tips, nothing. Thorough gentleman.
4. KS Tires - replaced the tires and did good job of fitting and balancing/alignment
5. Hyundai RSA team called multiple times during the day to follow-up on the status of the complaint and resolution
What could have been done better:
1. Quality control or design choice on Hyundai’s part on choosing Apollo tires or choosing one with a 55 section for such a segment of car. Seems to be prone to sidewall bursts.
2. Coordination between Hyundai RSA team and Hyundai service centre to ensure tire of this size was available. There was ample time to make sure of this.
3. Communication between Hyundai RSA team and Towing recovery van on where to drop the vehicle - they asked us to choose where to drop the vehicle and having no idea of that area, I just searched on Google maps for the nearest service centre. Then too he took us to the accident workshop and Hyundai RSA team were completely unaware of where he had taken us.
4. It took from 10am - 4pm to locate a shop that had these tire size available. The problem solving could have been much better and a list of shops having this size of tire or even Hyundai’s own stockyards having supply of these tires is essential given that it is prone to these sidewall issues due to the 55 section.
5. No warranty/guarantee from Hyundai or Apollo for such an issue for a car that has been driven only 700 kms and is not even completed first 60 days of ownership.
I would only advise buyers of this car to be very careful when driving it over rough patches. Some photos are attached.
