Well.... before starting with my experience with Linea, let me tell you I don't hate FIAT, Maruti, TATA or Mahindra (even after Xylo). Neither am a Fanboy of any brands. I'm pretty a common man you can say.
Since many days I'm looking for a car. Perhaps more appropriate word is "thinking" than "looking" because of some "factors" (no prize for guessing). Currently I do have Wagon R, which is shared with my father. I rarely use it other than weekends. On the other hand my father is using it quite frequently now a days (which makes me see if the car is available for me). There comes the new car requirement. So a car for myself which also be used preferred over Wagon R for travelling out-station. So boot is kind of necessary.
So when I look for the car, what I see in one??
Performance,
Comfort,
Styling and over all look and feel,
FE,
and
VFM.
for me all the constraints are equally important. I don't want to compromise absence one against excellance for others.
Performance: I won't mind cars overtaking me, but definitely want to over take more cars than overtaken by. So I'm quite ok if the car isn't really performer like vtec (I would really love to have one though, but it's quite out of my budget).
Comfort: Cannot afford D class comfort, but surely will be happy with descent comfort level.
Styling and over all look and feel: It should definitely look nice and feel nice.
FE: Around 10 in city is fine.
VFM: Strictly yes. Absolutely no compromise.
So being happy Wagon R user (and M800 earlier), if my constraints are best satisfied, I won't spend a moment to Maruti again.
After various TDs, I selected Fiesta and SX4 but always kept expecting some nice surprises from Linea (as it was yet to be launched).
Linea arrived. And I went to see and TD Linea. Well I have to say I was quite impressed by the looks and interiors. (I won't mention them specifically as those are already praised quite often in this thread) Now the question was how it performs. Only MJD was available then, so went for it. It had a decent performance. Loved the 3rd gear performance though. I kept thinking about Linea next two days though it didn't match the accelaration of Fiesta(petrol) and SX4. As Linea was the only diesel sedan I TDed, next week I went to check diesel models of Fiesta and Logan and Linea MJD immediately after them. I started inclining towards Linea, but I was more interested in Petrol.
One day while reading on T-BHP, it turned out petrols are available now. So went again for a TD. Thankfully the sales person didn't try any cranking prank on me. But yes, it is really difficult to tell if engine is running or not in idle condition. Also felt that it accelerates faster than MJD. But it doesn't sound aggressive as SX4 (which I personally like).
So now it's time for commenting Linea against my constraints.
Performance: For petrol it's an average performer when other petrol sedans are considered. But has an edge when MJD Linea is concerned. For Diesel, definitely above average than other Diesel sedans.
Comfort: Definitely above average in the segment.
Styling and over all look and feel: One of the best in segment.
FE: You can expect petrol variant to return in double digits. For MJD you already know what engine is capable of.
VFM: Very good value for money. It gives definitely more than what you have paid for.
Now the conclusion time.
If you have somewhat similar constraint, if you are looking for a car which doesn't exceed in some and fail in some, but does well for all the constraints, if budget is holding you to find a car which satisfies these constraints, (in short if you are me)
This car is for you.
Indeed if you don't mind stretching your budget by around 2 Lacks (that's quite a lot of money for a guy who recently has bought a home, recently have been married and working today with software firm [just like me
]), ANHC is the car for you.
Though A.S.S. is a problem for FIAT, it will be very unfare to rule out this car off the board.
P.S.
Some people might want to jump on me as I did not mentione Linea as "underpowered". Instead of which I'm mentioning average for petrol and above average for diesel. Please note that the comparison is between same segment petrol and same segment diesel. (please refrain comparing Linea MJD with other petrol cars)
Here are some numbers to judge whether Linea is "underpowered" or not.
Please correct me if I'm wrong.