Hi Everyone
Been following all the helpful, smart insights and pearls of wisdom that this community has to share. A big shout out to all of you for keeping the rest of us up to speed.
I got my Jeep Compass Limited Plus 4x4 Diesel AT in October 2020. I had a Skoda Octavia Diesel 2.0 AT earlier. Used it for 175000 kms and absolutely loved that car to bits. What that car offered at that price tag was unmatched. But it required some major work which I was skeptical about so decided we needed a replacement.
My usual travel involves a lot of highway travel on NH-44 and the car had to be a good highway companion. Dad travels along with me so rear seat comfort was also necessary. Driving dynamics were of high importance since I will be self driving often. Diesel and AT were also a must because of the amount of traveling and the NCR traffic along with the ongoing highway construcion on NH-44. With these things in mind I set out to find a worthy replacement.
The first choice was a like for like replacement i.e. Skoda Superb since I was in love with my Octavia. Arya Skoda in Moti Nagar could never arrange a test drive vehicle for even a month to give me a test drive. That got me to looking for other options. Narrowed down to 3:
1) Skoda Superb
2) Jeep Compass
3) Tata Harrier
I test drove the Jeep Compass first since it was right opposite Arya Skoda. Loved the drive from the first moment. It felt really comfortable at low speeds and absorbed the bumps well. The other knick knacks were in place so it was a positive first experience.
Next, since Arya were callous enough to not follow up or offer a test drive, I headed to Sidak Skoda in Karnal to test drive. Had everything to love with the Superb as it was just a duplicate of the Octavia (and not the other way around). There was a jaw dropping discount on offer including loyalty/exchange also. It was costing me about 35 lacs OTR. The only concern was the Petrol AT offering only and the repeated reliability issues cited multiple times on the forum.
There was a Jeep dealership nearby so TD'ed the Compass again this time on a highway to gauge the highway ride. That is when the limitations of the Diesel AT box became apparent. You just can't push it hard until the 3rd/4th gear. But beyond that you will be surprised at the way it picks up pace and it gets real fast real quick. The dealer didn't have anything much to offer by way of discount and didn't have many vehicles in yard either.
Went to Tata next for the Harrier. It was a decent test drive. The Harrier AT was much smoother to drive than the Compass. But there was a lot of body roll and you felt the bigger size of the car. The comfort was also slightly less as compared to Jeep Compass.
Finally went to Landmark Jeep again and TD'ed the Limited Compass 4x4 AT again and booked it for ~28 lacs OTR (including the MOPAR rubber mats). What finally clinched it in favor of Jeep Compass even though it was a full Rs 4 lac more expensive than the Harrier and not as pleasurable as the Skoda was the combination of Diesel AT, better ride dynamics and the fact that NH-44 was going to be constructed in the lifetime of this car and I expect it to withstand the punishment.
It's close to 11000 kms at the time of writing and I have to say I am a bit neutral on Jeep Compass right now. It's serving its purpose well, especially now that NH-44 is closed due to farmer protest and we have to go through all kinds of roads, farms and what not. The rattles and squeaks have crept up like in a lot of other posts mentioned here and will be checked up at the first service. I am really disappointed though in the AT gearbox. It would have been good enough with a 7 speed but the 9 speed is just hunting for gears and it is heartbreaking. Plus you cannot rev above 2500 rpm even in manual mode

. The infotainment unit hangs once in a while when Android Auto is connected and you are using multiple features such as navigation, audio streaming and a call comes in. The car throws you around on big bumps and potholes and the thuds are quite audible. The FE is around 10.6 kmpl all included and the car has used up 15 lts of DEF since delivery. I plan to keep it for another couple of years till the highway mess is sorted and then move to greener pastures.
Apologies for the long post and thanks for taking the time to read.
Mod Note : Please do NOT use acronyms (e.g. ANHC, MS, T-Fort, JC) when referring to cars or their makers. You are ONLY permitted to use the full Make & Model name. This will make our content useful, searchable & easy-to-understand for experts & newbies alike.
Thanks for the support & understanding